嘉宾访谈·中文精读

自由与安全:Axon CEO 里克·史密斯谈警务未来

Freedom vs. Safety: Axon CEO Rick Smith on the Future of Policing

Axon CEO 里克·史密斯回顾公司从濒临破产到上市、转向警务并押注执法记录仪与云软件,讨论无人机、机器人及自由与安全之争。

官方音频00:00 / --:--

本期章节点时间可跳到音频对应位置

  1. 0:00Axon 首席执行官里克·史密斯对话大卫·弗里德伯格
  2. 2:39泰瑟/Axon 发展史:从破产边缘到 IPO
  3. 9:05互联网泡沫破裂期间上市,向警方销售,应对做空者与 SEC 调查,转向软件
  4. 20:47打造警用执法记录仪,Flock 引发监控国家担忧
  5. 35:25自由与安全、Skydio 交易、泰瑟无人机项目争议
  6. 45:24警务机器人系统与无人机的未来
中文精读由 AI 基于原始节目改写,非官方翻译,可能存在偏差或错误;观点归属与表述以原音频与官方文稿为准。说明

1998 年,里克·史密斯(Rick Smith)打算关掉自己的公司。

他刚经历第二次产品失败。那批在硅谷打工的大学同学,正在名字古怪的公司里(比如雅虎)赚得手抽筋,而他连电费都快付不出。他去找父亲,说我们认输吧。

父亲告诉他,现在关有点晚了:公司欠硅谷银行 200 万美元,自己是担保人,手上还剩 50 万。关掉的话,银行把东西全拿走,老头子跟着一起完蛋。

于是父亲把最后 50 万美元投了进去,另一位投资人布鲁斯·卡尔弗(Bruce Culver)跟投 50 万。这是这家公司能拿到的最后一笔钱,之后只能靠它自己活下去。

二十五年后,这家公司叫 Axon,市值三百亿美元上下。

里克·史密斯在 All-In 的这期访谈里,把这三十多年的账从头翻了一遍:怎么在车库里做出第一支电击枪,怎么在互联网泡沫破灭时上市,怎么被做空机构、SEC 和几百起官司围剿,又怎么靠执法记录仪把一家武器公司改造成软件公司。他还回答了那个绕不开的问题:当警用技术越来越强,公民的自由还剩多少。

一个没有 VC 愿意投的创业项目

公司 1993 年诞生在图森的一间车库里。起因是他在欧洲读研究生,一群欧洲同学说不敢去美国,因为电视上全是枪击。他本能地想反驳,说新闻不等于现实。有人问他:你认识被枪打死的人吗?

他认真数了数,想起高中橄榄球队的两个队友死于一场路怒,加上几家认识的朋友,一共五六个人。那一刻他冒出的念头是:为什么到了 1993 年,子弹还是唯一的选择?

如果我们有柯克船长的相位枪,人们会选择不杀对方,因为他们有一个更文明的方式阻止威胁自己的人。(里克·史密斯)

他顺着专利文件找到了 TASER 的发明人,一位住在图森的 NASA 科学家,七十年代就做出了原型。他打电话过去问这东西怎么没下文了,对方请他到家里坐坐。23 岁的年轻人对上 73 岁的老发明家,他劝老人结束退休生活,一起把它做出来。

第一台原型机 30 天左右就成型,零件来自 Ace Hardware。当时最要紧的事是拿到联邦层面的认定,证明这种新装置不算非法武器。

钱来自朋友和家人。他父亲是连续创业者,在硅谷有过一家成功的公司,认识一堆 VC,但没有一家愿意投。理由很直白:1993 到 1999 年正是互联网泡沫的顶峰,一家做电击枪的公司,怎么看都像怪胎。

更麻烦的是法律地位。老款 TASER 本质上是火器,外形却像手电筒,于是被归入「第二类」,等同于锯短枪管的霰弹枪,普通人几乎买不到。他们改用压缩空气代替火药,绕开这个分类,本来的设想是卖给消费者:他母亲那阵子刚买了一把枪,他希望母亲能有个别的东西可选。

消费市场做了七年,失败了七年。消费者给了一句最难回答的话:如果这东西真有用,为什么警察不用?

1999 年底,公司整体转向警用市场,生意才真正开始。前七年把一项技术上的猜想,变成了一个可以被现场验证的产品问题。

罗德尼·金那一枪,把技术门槛定死了

九十年代末,TASER 在执法圈的名声很差,而且这个差评是应得的。

罗德尼·金被 LAPD 的 TASER 击中,没有倒下,警察转用警棍,后果举世皆知。里克自己送出去的第一代样机同样停不住一个专注而暴怒的人,对方能硬扛过疼痛继续打。

真正的突破来自动物实验:他们反复调校神经刺激的剂量,直到能让目标彻底失去行动能力。这是个不好看但必须做的活。技术过关之后,销售反而变得极简单。

公司没钱打广告,雇了一个前海军陆战队员,叫汉斯,开着房车全国跑。进警局,讲完产品,掏出一张一百美元钞票:你要是能扛住,这一百块归你。多数警察愿意试,被击中,倒地,拍掉身上的土,说同一句话,比想象中强太多。有人不服气要再来一次,然后当场就明白了这东西的价值。

我不知道听过多少警察跟我说,天哪,这东西本来能让我不用开枪,也不用跟一个极度危险的人滚在地上扭打。(里克·史密斯)

2000 年前后,订单开始进来,一年内现金流打平。2001 年公司上市,估值大约 1200 万美元。

2004 年全球表现第一的股票,2005 年从 33 美元跌到 7 美元

上市之后的四年疯狂得不像真的,营收每年翻三倍。2004 年,按一年期和三年期回报算,它是全球表现最好的股票,里克把《华尔街日报》那篇报道裱起来挂在墙上。

然后是 2004 年底的 SEC 调查。指控很重:为了拉高股价,公司对产品的安全性撒谎。

同期还有一场做空攻击。最离谱的细节是,他的私人助理其实是做空方的内线,持续把内部文件送出去,做空方再转手给《纽约时报》,而《纽约时报》在报道里承认,自己拿到的是来自做空方的内幕信息。2005 年,股价从 33 美元跌到 7 美元。

客户群体的反应比股价更致命。警察局的说法很一致:老兄,你正在被联邦调查,我没办法拿这个去市议会要预算。采购直接停摆。

他做了一件律师明确反对的事:抱着几箱文件走进旧金山 SEC 办公室,说自己愿意配合把调查尽快做完,因为再拖下去公司就要倒闭了。调查最后以「无发现」结案,这就是能拿到的最好结果。

更难的是诉讼。前后从零变成几百起,任何被警用电击枪打中的人,起诉警察的同时都会把公司列进去。市值 2004 年底到过 20 亿美元,之后回落到 1 亿左右。一家一亿美元市值的公司扛着几百起官司,用里克的话说,本来就该倒闭。

转折点来自一次和保险公司的对赌。第一起案子,保险公司想赔 200 万美元和解。里克说不行,一旦开了这个口,后面所有案子都会涌上来。他给了对方一个方案:你照样付原告 200 万,付给我们的部分少一点,我们签走你的赔偿责任,这个案子由我们自己扛去开庭。他们这么干了两次,两次都赢,甚至赚了钱。

如果你告我们,最好把最好的状态拿出来。如果我们真做错了,我们会理性处理,会和解。但如果是我们认定自己占理的事,我们会像宗教狂热分子一样死磕到底,这就是保护了这家公司的东西。(里克·史密斯)

几十年过去,Axon 现在第一次做到零在诉案件。

哈迪·帕尔托维当了五年兼职 CTO,还说服他改掉公司名字

2007 到 2009 年,公司开始做执法记录仪,2010 年前后上线。里克从没建过软件公司,招的人不合适,技术问题一堆,他自己的说法是手上握着一起灾难。

他去找大学时代的朋友哈迪·帕尔托维(Hadi Partovi,Code.org 创始人),请对方进董事会。哈迪答应的其实不止是董事席位,接下来五年他基本是这家公司的兼职 CTO。

第一件被纠正的事是自建数据中心。他们原本打算自己建机房、自己运维,服务全国警局,结果出过一次近乎灾难的故障,差点把客户数据全丢光。

这世界上有很多难事值得做,自己运营一个数据中心不在其中。(哈迪·帕尔托维)

系统随后迁到 AWS,后来又迁到 Azure。里克的说法很直接:哈迪救了这家公司,是他教会自己怎么在一家武器公司内部长出软件业务。而在当时,股东们普遍认为 CEO 疯了,把武器公司改成软件公司听起来像个玩笑。

哈迪推动的第二件事更伤感情:改名。TASER 这个品牌意味着电击武器,是个大锤式的名字,而公司做的远不止这些。管理层一开始抵触,觉得改名像是撤退。后来的事证明哈迪是对的,今天 Axon 这个名字底下,电击枪只是很小的一块业务。

执法记录仪的起点,是一桩注定打不赢的官司

这项产品的动机来自法庭,跟市场调研无关。

里克在北加州旁听一起警察羁押致死的案子。死者是个四十岁的男人,有二十年的冰毒史,被抓那晚状态极糟。家属在庭上反复播放他高中毕业照,警察看着照片对里克说,那不是我那晚看到的人,我看到的东西像是从《驱魔人》里走出来的。一位干了二十六年的老警察告诉里克,他职业生涯里从没害怕过,直到那晚面对那个人的动物性暴怒。

这些都没能传达给陪审团。警察在法庭上必须极度克制,只能说「赫斯顿先生做了这个、做了那个」,家属用的是情绪、色彩和画面感。

我跟他们说,你们被打得很惨,你们得用更多激情讲你们的故事。他们说,里克,我们不能那么干。我们为政府工作,只要被抓到半句不实,职业生涯就结束了。(里克·史密斯)

那就录下来。让他们不必解释,直接给全世界看。

这段创业史里也有荒唐的部分。负责做第一台警用记录仪的员工半夜辞职,一周后自己发布了产品。调查发现,他用来做这个竞品的钱,来自他自己的股票期权。两家后来和解,Axon 把这家公司收了回来。

产品做出来了,没人愿意戴,这个僵局持续了七年。警察的说辞都一样:这是老大哥,是上级拿来挑刺的工具。公司押了两个注,一个是摄像头,一个是云,因为一万八千个警局各自搭视频服务器根本不可能规模化。云在当时对政府客户还非常陌生,普遍的想法是数据存在我楼里才安全。里克的第一性原理判断是,网络安全取决于技术栈和人,普通警局自建的机房未必比得过专业云厂商。

打破僵局的是一句来自警察工会领袖的话。

没有警察愿意戴执法记录仪,直到他戴满九十天。之后你不让他戴,他就不出勤。(一位警察工会领袖)

原因是另一面:嫌疑人撒谎毫无心理负担。里克跟车巡逻时听一位警察讲了自己的经历。他逮捕一个吸毒后近乎半裸的性工作者,把人放进后座开往警局,对方突然开始尖叫:我现在就要说你强奸了我,你要是不停车放我走,我就这么说。警察回了一句:女士,提醒一下,这是执法记录仪,从上车到现在全程在录,你想说什么都可以,但都被录下来了。对方的情绪瞬间平复。

你想想,如果没有这台机器,我一个男人被指控强奸,变成各说各话,那可能是终结职业生涯的指控,而我没有任何办法自证。(一位警察)

真正的引爆点是 2014 年弗格森,迈克尔·布朗案。家属的说法是「举起手,别开枪」,那是冷血谋杀;警官威尔逊的说法是双方在争抢配枪,他眼眶上方骨折。后续审查大体支持警察的陈述,但当时没有任何证据能证明。案发之后,家属要求装摄像头,警察工会也要求装,双方第一次达成一致。

十年之后出现了一个反转。当年最积极推动执法记录仪的民权组织,现在有一部分开始说这套系统「坏了」,理由是没有如预期地抓出大量坏警察。里克的观点相反:那恰恰说明绝大多数警察在正常执法,并且经常被诬告。

今天几乎所有大型警局都配了执法记录仪,绝大多数跑在 Axon 的系统上。超过一百万警察每天各上传约两小时视频。按数据量算,他们每天管理的视频比 YouTube 还多,虽然观众数完全不在一个量级。

摄像头比人多的年代,真问题是数据怎么治理

杰森提到 Flock 的处境:这家在全美城市铺车牌识别摄像头的公司,开始被市议会投票拒绝。更早的导火索是 Ring 的超级碗广告,很多人看完的第一反应是恶心,觉得整个社区被人盯着。

里克没有否认这种情绪。他把这归入对 AI 和传感器泛滥的整体焦虑,并且认为这种焦虑不算不合理,没有人想活在一个每个公民的行踪都被记录的国家。

但他认为讨论的起点错了。

我们回不到 1950 年代的美国了。事实是摄像头已经无处不在,比人还多。你和我光手机上就有四个,家里可能还有十几个。(里克·史密斯)

真正要解决的是数据治理规则:在什么条件下,社会应该把这些画面交给政府,政府又该怎么用。

Axon 自己也做车牌识别。他承认真正让人愤怒的场景是警察拿系统去搜前女友这类私人用途,这在道德上无法辩护。但追踪失窃车辆、调取暴力犯罪现场周边的车牌,这些用途在民意上是被接受的。

他特意提到,最有思想的那批批评者并不主张废掉技术,他们要的是护栏。这也是他支持参议员乔什·霍利(Josh Hawley)正在推动的立法的原因:警察个人滥用要有刑事和民事处罚;对厂商则要求搜索前必须有可核验的案件编号,并且需要两个执法系统之间的协作,也就是你得找到另一个愿意拿职业生涯陪你冒险的警官,才能发起一次查询。

这套设计能说服九成理性关注这件事的人,剩下的那一成说服不了。里克的判断是,护栏到位之后,情绪会慢慢退潮。

他还给了一个容易被忽略的观察:最欢迎这些技术的,往往是犯罪率最高的贫困社区。反对声最强烈的多半来自富裕社区,因为那里还停留在理论层面。

你去跟那些每天面对枪击的人聊,警察出现的时候他们是欢呼的,他们要的是更强的威慑。(里克·史密斯)

伦理委员会集体辞职的那件事

2022 年 6 月,Axon 宣布研发可搭载电击枪的无人机,用来应对校园枪击。消息出来后,公司 AI 伦理委员会的成员集体辞职抗议,认为这个项目在伦理上不该做。

里克没有停掉项目,这也是他们辞职的原因。他给出的反问很具体:今天有人拿着枪走进美国任何一栋楼,我们是怎么阻止的?

我们派更多拿枪的人进去,然后发生枪战。这就是一个社会能拿出的最好办法吗?(里克·史密斯)

他强调的区分是:没有任何警察会拿着非致命武器去面对持枪者,这不合逻辑。但如果先送进去的是一台无人机或机器人,局面就完全不同了,非致命手段第一次变得可行。而且每一次枪战都会带来无辜路人的伤亡。

他承认这件事背后有现实的人事因素。当时正值弗洛伊德事件之后,部分顾问在大学工作,已经被指责亲警,他们担心被取消。里克的说法是,很多人私下同意他的判断,但认为政治风险太高。

值得一提的是后续处理。很多公司在类似风波之后直接解散了伦理委员会,Axon 选择重组,改名为「公平与伦理顾问委员会」,并且显著增加了黑人和棕色人种的声音。原因来自当时的一条批评:既然要讨论过度执法,会议室里就该坐着受影响最深的社区的人,而原来的委员会太学术了。

里克的复盘是,把批评者请进设计阶段,能改的东西很多;等到产品发布之后再听,能做的只剩辩论。

未来的现场:无人机先到,人在后面同时拧几把钥匙

Axon 最近成了 Skydio 最大的投资方,买了接近一半的股份。但他特意让这家公司保持独立,理由是创业公司需要以创业速度前进,融资和花钱不该受上市公司框架约束。作为交换,Axon 拿到了自己关心的市场的独家渠道。

Skydio 做的是自主停机坞:无人机停在消防站楼顶,接到报警几秒内起飞,有时 911 接线员还没把单子录完,画面已经传回来了。这直接减少了警察为误报出警的次数,把人力腾给真正的紧急事件。控制措施也一起做进去了,警局可以把飞行任务档案对公众开放,多数机构的规定是只在有人求助时飞过去,不做日常巡逻。

再往前看,他划了一条明确的界线:警务归根到底是人的工作,任何对他人使用武力的决定必须由人做出。

技术上的应对是多密钥流程。任何警官要从无人机或机器人上使用哪怕是非致命武器,系统都可以要求管理员实时批准。

我们要造的是警务史上最不容易被滥用的技术。今天你给警察一把枪,他走出门,你对他做什么毫无控制,只能事后追责。(里克·史密斯)

杰森用一个具体场景追问自由的边界:警察拿到线报说你家藏着重犯,这种走错门的事真实发生过。里克的回答是把今天和未来摆在一起比。

今天是几名穿防弹衣、手持致命武器的警官破门而入,肾上腺素飙升,要在瞬间做出生死判断。人在战或逃的状态下做不出好决定。而政府本来就垄断着合法的武力使用。换成机器人或无人机进去,操作者是一个团队而不是一个人,不在恐惧中,手指不会抖着扣扳机;就算判断失误,落在你身上的是一发电击或胡椒喷雾;整个过程必然被录下来,而今天大量警察开枪根本没有影像记录。

他也不想走另一个极端。

我不想活在一个其他所有人都有机器人和 AI,而警察开着 1974 年的雪佛兰、拿着老式对讲机来的世界。(里克·史密斯)

1968 年蒙特利尔那一夜

杰森问他对「削减警察经费」这股政治力量的看法。

里克的回答是,这件事不需要做实验,结果会是灾难性的。他举了 1968 年蒙特利尔警察罢工的例子:起因只是薪酬纠纷,没有任何种族冲突背景,但罪犯听说警察不上班了,城市当晚失控,后来被称为「恐怖之夜」。他提到史蒂芬·平克在《人性中的善良天使》里引用过这个案例,用来说明一支能运转的警察队伍是社会信任的地基。

他也把旧金山拿来当反面教材。弗格森事件之后,一些州事实上对入店行窃不再追究,后果是零售商撤走,工作机会消失,街区变成没有经济活动的荒漠。他的观察是,旧金山已经开始往回摆,纠错机制在起作用。

访谈最后,他给了一个时间尺度上的判断。几个月前《经济学人》的封面是「AI 就业末日」,两个月后又变成「AI 正在创造数百万个岗位」,公众不知道该信哪个。技术加速带来的不确定性是真实的,他给客户的话是:撑住,警务可能是维系社会秩序的最后一道粘合剂。

他自己是大乐观派,认为十到二十年后的社会近乎乌托邦,技术会治愈很多疾病,马斯克说的全民高收入会实现。但中间这段过渡期会很难,Axon 的角色是让警察在这段路上不至于赤手空拳,同时把约束条件先写进产品里。

  • 看技术公司的转型,看它敢不敢改掉自己的名字。TASER 改叫 Axon 那天,这家公司才真正从卖硬件变成卖系统。品牌名如果只锁定了你最赚钱的那个旧产品,它就会变成转型的天花板。
  • 监管争议出现时,先分清是「技术该不该存在」还是「数据该怎么用」。里克把摄像头之争重新定义为数据治理问题,这个切法值得学。前者吵不出结果,后者可以写进法条,可以做成产品功能。
  • 把最强硬的批评者请进设计阶段。Axon 的伦理委员会集体辞职过一次,但他们没有解散,而是换了一批更贴近受影响社区的人。产品发布后再听批评,你只剩辩论的余地;设计阶段听,还能改。
  • 创业前七年找不到市场,先问是产品不行还是买家不对。消费市场失败七年后转向警用,同一套技术在另一群客户那里一年就打平现金流。
  • 面对诉讼和做空,和解与硬扛是两种战略选择,跟性格无关。Axon 宁可与自己的保险公司对赌也要把第一案打到底,因为一旦开了和解的口子,后面几百起会一起涌来。什么时候硬扛,取决于你判断对方是在试探底线还是在解决纠纷。
  • 如果你在评估公共安全领域的投资或就业机会,无人机比人形机器人来得更快。里克的原话是无人机规模会更大、速度会更快,未来几年美国会部署数百万架。人形机器人会来,但不在同一个时间表上。
文稿来自 All-In 官网(allin.com)发布的官方 Transcript,说话人按官网分轨数据标注,个别段落可能张冠李戴。
Jason Calacanis (00:00:00): What is it like being tased? Rick Smith (00:00:01): So it's really interesting. It's terrifying while it's happening because you lose control of your body, and there's, like, these waves of energy. Five seconds while you're being hit with a taser seems like a very long time, and I had long enough to, like, have this philosophical, like, realization about what it must be like for people who can't control their body and then the the current was off. Yeah. It's it's it's not fun. But when it's off, it's off. Like, you're right back to normal the second it's off. Jason Calacanis (00:00:25): Am I the only person who thinks that there's a great content business in body camps? There's just so much good content that comes out of these things. Like, is that just crazy? It's not just valuable from a social perspective, but it's like there's a ton of entertaining content. Rick Smith (00:00:39): Well, was a company that... Remember Live PD? I know if you remember that? No. There was a show that did just live PD on Friday nights. They were The cops. Jason Calacanis (00:00:48): Remember cops? This kid I went to high school with, his dad produced cops on TV. I I guess it's always been interesting. Rick Smith (00:00:54): Yeah. So live PD was the new version of cops. Jason Calacanis (00:00:57): I see. Rick Smith (00:00:57): And their twist was that it was live so people would tune in on on weekend nights because they're like, oh, I wanna see what's happening, like a live sporting event. But then they got canceled after the George Floyd incident. You know, I think the production companies were afraid to be sharing, you know, pro police. So we we actually ourselves had done Axon Studios for a period of time to try to do exactly what you're talking about, like a, you know, live content business out of the body cameras. But it's just... Know, you gotta know your corporate DNA. We we are too, like, pro police and we're, like, you know, we're a we're a big corporation that wasn't gonna do the edgy things you would need to do to make that a great content business. Yeah. But I think it's it's there for somebody to do it. Jason Calacanis (00:01:42): Yeah. Well, YouTube works. AppLovin started with an $8 domain, no VC funding and became one of the largest ad platforms in the world. Now that same engine powers AppLovin ads for ecommerce. Your ads run inside mobile games reaching over a billion people with full screen distraction free attention. The platform finds buyers and optimizes for profit. You see the target, it does the rest. One cookware brand went from 4,000,000 to 16,000,000, turned profitable, and is on pace for 80,000,000 this year. Visit apploving.com/allin to launch your first campaign today. Rick Smith, CEO of Axon. Welcome to the All In interview. Rick Smith (00:02:26): It's awesome to be here. Jason Calacanis (00:02:28): Thanks. I'm glad we could make this work out. I know we had talked about having you come out to the summit and got delayed, Missed that window, but I'm really glad that this has worked out. You know, your business history is is fascinating. I would love if you're okay with it maybe to go back a little bit to the beginning of the business. Your company used to be called Taser. I think we all remember the original Taser name and product. But maybe you could take us back, like, we could do a real quick recap how the company got started in the early days. Rick Smith (00:02:57): Yeah. So we started in the early nineties. So this is the only job I've ever had. Started in '93 in a garage in Tucson. The sort of lead up to that is I was in graduate school in Europe, and a bunch of the European students were saying they were afraid to come to America because of all the gun violence they were seeing on TV. And I would tell them, like, you know, look. That's not not everything is like what you see on the news. And one of them asked me if I knew anyone who'd been shot and killed, and it just struck me. Was like, wow. Actually, I do. There were these two guys that played on my high school football team that were shot and killed in a road rage incident and we knew a couple friends of the family. By the time I added it up, it was, like, maybe five or six people. And the thing that struck me was why is it that, like, bullets are still a thing in 1993, much less 2026? And what I mean is, like, it's a pretty old technology. Right? I mean, bullets have been around for many centuries. And the simple insight was if we had captain Kirk's phaser, like, people would choose not to kill other people because they'd have a more civilized way to stop somebody who's threatening them. And one thing led to another. I discovered this device called the TASER had been invented back in the nineteen seventies by a NASA scientist who lived in Tucson, Arizona. I found him through his patent filings. And one thing led to another. I just called him up and I said, hey, man. Whatever happened to this this tech? It seems to me like this is something the world could use. And shortly thereafter, he invited me down to his house and here I am, this 23 year old kid and this 73 year old man. It sounds like, I don't know, a a comic book sort of plot. But we started in his garage to build new TASERs. And I can tell you, at the beginning, everybody thought I'd lost my mind. In fact, I have a great video of Emil Mayku, is one of the leaders at Uber. He's now the undersecretary of war, came to visit me when he was 23, and they filmed a spoof video making fun of me just how crazy this idea was that I was gonna go make electrical weapons. Jason Calacanis (00:04:55): So you found the inventor of the TASER device through a patent filing, go and visit him and buy it or license it and form a company around it? Rick Smith (00:05:04): Yep. In fact, I convinced him to do it with me to come out of retirement and sort of show me the way. So we were building the first TASERs in his garage from parts from Ace Hardware because the first thing we had to do was to get federal government approval that the new TASER would not be considered some sort of illegal weapon and that would require a regulatory approval. As I look back, you just you don't realize how fast you move when you're a startup relative to the rest of the world. Like, we built our first prototype in thirty days from Go. You know, now I've got 6,000 What Jason Calacanis (00:05:35): was this? Rick Smith (00:05:36): It was '93. Jason Calacanis (00:05:37): '93. Rick Smith (00:05:39): You started Jason Calacanis (00:05:39): a company right away and built the first prototype with your own money? Rick Smith (00:05:43): Yeah. It was friends and family. My... No. My dad was a serial entrepreneur and he had had one successful company in Silicon Valley. So he knew a lot of the VCs but no VC would touch us. Right? We weren't the Internet in late nineties. It was right in the peak Internet boom. And, again, everybody thought we were this sort of oddball oddball thing. And I'm actually pretty proud now that we've seen enough success that and with the changes in the world, that defense and policing technology is now much more mainstream than it was back then. But this was a handheld Jason Calacanis (00:06:17): TASER device. What what was the market initially? Was it to sell into police forces? How did you think you were gonna go to market, and what what was your first sale? Rick Smith (00:06:27): Yeah. Jason Calacanis (00:06:27): No. Rick Smith (00:06:27): Our first our our first market was consumers. So, you know, police could buy the original TASER, but due to... Basically, the original taser was a firearm, but it looked like a flashlight. That puts it into this category two, which is like a sawed off shotgun, which effectively makes it illegal. Very hard to buy it. But police could still buy them. So our theory was if we made this new taser weapon using compressed air instead of gunpowder, it would not be a firearm, and then people like my mom could go buy it to defend herself. And she had recently bought a gun around that same time. So we started in the consumer market, and we struggled and we didn't really succeed. And what we heard from consumers was, hey. If this thing, really works, why aren't the police using it? And so we basically realized we we need to go prove this works in policing. So after seven years of struggling and failing, we pivoted into the police market in late ninety nine, and that's when the business took off. But like MacArthur to The Philippines, I will return to the consumer market once we have proven with police that the taser is as effective or even more effective than a gun, and that will happen in the next five years. Jason Calacanis (00:07:36): And so you spent seven years developing the market, trying to find product market fit all off of friends and family money. What was keeping you in it? Was there a point where you said, hey, I'm gonna throw the towel in. We should go do something else with I my mean, this is kind of a classic entrepreneur, you know, how many times are you willing to pivot question. Rick Smith (00:07:56): Yeah. So we we had two failed product launches. And then in 1998, I was visiting some of my friends up in Silicon Valley who'd taken jobs, you know, at at companies with dumb names like Yahoo. And, of course, they were all making money hand over fist. It was the Internet Gold Rush. And here I just failed on my second product. And I remember going to my dad. It was it was him and one of his friends that were funding this. And I said, look, I I think we should just shut it down. You know, we failed twice. And my dad looked at me and he said, well, you know, it would have been nice to figure that out a couple years ago because we owe Silicon Valley Bank about $2,000,000. I have $500,000 and I'm on the hook. So if we shut down, the bank has taken everything. So we have no choice. I'm putting my last 500,000 in and the other investor was a guy named Bruce Culver. Shout out Bruce if you're watching. Bruce matched him and so we... That was going to be the last $1,000,000 we would ever get. We would have to survive on it. And with that, we managed to design, tool, manufacture, and launch the police taser and then shoestring it along to cash flow breakeven and eventually an IPO two years later. Jason Calacanis (00:09:05): So you go public around Rick Smith (00:09:07): the Jason Calacanis (00:09:07): end of the .com boom, right? So the market's kinda tanking generally and there's an opportunity because you guys now have revenue. You're selling into what? Police forces? That's the primary market at that point? Rick Smith (00:09:17): Yeah. It was. And and actually looking back on it, it was just an alignment of the fates. So, yeah, the Internet bubble popped in 2000. And in late two thousand, an investment bank came to one of our training events and they basically were like, oh my gosh, you're not Internet. You guys make a physical product. You have real revenue. We're taking you public. And and so we went public specifically, I think, because banks needed deals and we were not Internet. And we went public at a massive, about $12,000,000 valuation. Jason Calacanis (00:09:50): Wow. Rick Smith (00:09:51): And that was a Jason Calacanis (00:09:51): big that was a big outcome though. Right? Mean, you guys owned a 100% of the company. You didn't have VCs or institutional guys on the cap table. Rick Smith (00:09:59): That's right. Yeah. I mean, we were a tiny tiny market cap to go public, but because of that, you know, we ended up being the the highest return I think that investment bank Paulson out of Oregon ever had. That's awesome. And and for us, like, I'll tell you, for me, it was just... It was such a relief that we were able to raise enough money to be able to pay off some shareholder notes so that I knew my dad wasn't gonna end up in the poorhouse. That was Yeah. To me, the biggest relief is not destroying your family. And then everything from there has been gravy. Jason Calacanis (00:10:28): How do you cross that chasm those early days? You show up to a police force. You've got this handheld device that shoots out these electrodes that go into someone's skin and zaps them and they fall to the ground. They get incapacitated. What was the way that you kinda got these guys who had never heard of or seen anything like this before to make those first POs? How do you start to get those orders to come in? Yeah. And was there a moment where suddenly enough police forces had this where everyone's like, we all gotta have this, and then the market just kinda took off? Rick Smith (00:10:59): Yeah. So, I mean, this is one of those things where, look, you just don't overcomplicate life. We didn't have enough money to do anything fancy, and the main thing was we had solved a real problem. So the early generation TASERs were not powerful enough. Like, Rodney King was shot with an LAPD TASER and it did not work. And they went to the batons with catastrophic consequences. So TASER had a terrible reputation in the late nineties, and it was deserved because I'd sent several demos of our first generation product that also didn't stop somebody who was focused and aggressive. They could fight through the pain. So the thing we had done was we had basically done some animal testing to go tune the amount of nerve stimulation so that it would actually paralyze somebody. Once we did that, the launch was pretty simple. We didn't have money for a big ad campaign. We hired a former marine and put him in a Winnebago going around the country with a $100 bill, and he would go into a police department, explain to them what we're doing. And up until then, nonlethal weapons were seen as kinda snake oil. Like they... Like, yeah, pepper spray hurts, but you can fight through it. We had the first weapon that could actually stop somebody. And cops are an interesting crowd. You know, there's a fair amount of bravery, shall we say, and so they weren't afraid. They're like, okay. You think this would work? Fine. Let's give it a try. And we would offer them a $100 if they could come and take it. And we hit them. They would fall down. They'd dust themselves off and go, oh my god. That was way more powerful than I was expecting. Some would try again, and then immediately they saw the value. I mean, I can't tell you how many times I've had cops tell me, my gosh. Like, this would have prevented me from shooting someone or getting in a knockdown drag out fight with a very dangerous person. Rick Smith (00:12:36): So the value prop was so simple. We just had to convince them it worked, and we did that with very simple demos. And and and from that, you could see suddenly purchase orders started coming in, and we could track where Hans was going across the country, our trainer. And, you know, within a year, we hit cash flow breakeven. Jason Calacanis (00:12:54): And then you had like a decade where the stock kind of stayed in the same range, didn't it? Yeah. A lot of people think like, okay, go public, this thing's gonna take off, we're on some growth trajectory, but again, after how many years? Seven years of being a private company, eight years of kinda getting to that point of having an IPO, you then spend another decade kind of with this valuation in this range of a couple bucks a share. Right? Rick Smith (00:13:18): Oh, yeah. No. Actually, let me give you... It's more exciting than that. So seven years of, like, are we gonna survive? We can't pay the light bill. Then we go public in 2001, and the next four years are insane. We're growing it like... We're we're tripling every year. In 2004, we were the number one performing stock in the world. I have the Wall Street Journal article on the wall. On a one and three year return basis, we were number one. Jason Calacanis (00:13:42): Does it... Your Google went public? Yeah. Rick Smith (00:13:45): Yeah. Yeah. I mean, we we were on fire. Then what happened in late two thousand four, we got we got hit with an SEC investigation. There were allegations we'd lied about the safety of our products in order to pump up the stock price. Now, we could do a whole hour on this. There was a short selling attack. We had big short positions in the stock. My personal assistant was actually a mole for short sellers who was selling Oh my gosh. Really? It was crazy. Sending internal documents to short sellers that were giving them to the New York Times who was then disclosing they were getting internal confidential material nonpublic information from short sellers who were somehow getting it out of our company. So that was miserable. 2005, our stock dropped from 33 to $7 a share, and it was, yeah, it was miserable. I mean, you're wondering if you're gonna survive. Our customers are police, so they stopped buying from us. They're like, look, dude. You're under federal investigation. Like, I can't go to my city council until this is over. So ignoring my lawyer's advice, I walked into the front offices of the SEC office in San Francisco with boxes of documents and said, hey, guys. I wanna help you complete your investigation because I may go out of business if this drags on. And then that's when the long doldrums began. Like, the stock never fully recovered from there and we were But possibly Jason Calacanis (00:15:03): that investigation. That investigation, you moved on from it? Rick Smith (00:15:06): Oh, yeah. I mean, they don't give you a gold star when they're done and tell you good job. They just say no findings and they move on, which is as good as it gets. Turns out, though, what doesn't kill you makes you stronger. In that case, we had gone from zero lawsuits to hundreds of lawsuits. I mean, we were being sued obviously by shareholders. We were being sued by plaintiffs of of... Like, anybody who got shot by a police taser was now suing the police and us because we were all over the news. And we did a couple things there. Jason Calacanis (00:15:34): So What's your market cap during this time? Rick Smith (00:15:37): It it peaked about 2,000,000,000 in late two thousand four and then it was backed about a 100,000,000. Jason Calacanis (00:15:43): So you're... You get hundreds of lawsuits when you're kind of like a $100,000,000 market cap company that you're dealing with. Rick Smith (00:15:48): Yeah. We should have gone under. Like, we should not have survived. It was only by pure grit and frankly a little bit of craziness. Like, we our our our insurance company... Because we have insurance like everybody and we go to trial on our first cases. Our insurance company wanted to settle this first case for, like, around $2,000,000. And we said, hell no. You can't. If you settle this case, we will get swamped in litigation. You're putting our business at risk. If you settle the case, we'll sue you. But we're gonna give you an out. If you will pay the plaintiff $2,000,000, we'll take a little bit less. You can pay us and we'll sign away our liability and we'll take it across the goal line. We did that twice. We actually made money on those cases because we won. But the point is this was this was slightly what was considered crazy behavior that we would settle with our own insurance to prevent them from giving a dime to the plaintiffs because we believed we were right and it worked. Like today, for the first time, I should knock on wood, for the first time in decades, we now have zero litigation cases. Because if you sue us, you better bring your a game. Like, if we... Now, if we did something wrong, gonna be rational and we will settle. We're reasonable people. But you sue us on something where we think, you know, we're in the right, we will... We dig in like religious fanatics to defend our belief system and that's important and that's what protected our business. Jason Calacanis (00:17:08): This lasts for years. Right? These lawsuits, this market cap kind of being static. This this went on till, what, about 2012 or so? Yeah. And Rick, a buddy of mine, Hadi Partovi, is on your board. Right? Rick Smith (00:17:21): He is. Jason Calacanis (00:17:21): Yeah. And so he's been on your board for a long time. First of all, how'd you guys meet? And second of all, he mentioned some story about the role he played early on in keeping the business alive. Can you tell us what happened? Rick Smith (00:17:32): Oh, yeah. I cannot overstate his importance. So Hadi and I were friends in college. So he was one of my buddies who was out making a bunch of money in the Internet boom in the late nineties when I was struggling to get this taser business off the ground. Then what happened around two thousand seven, eight, nine, we were working on our body camera business and we launched... We were initially operational around 2010 or so and I frankly had a disaster on my hands. I had never built a software company. I'd hired a team let's just say we were struggling hard. And so I called Hadi and I was like, hey, man. I need some help. Like, I've started this software company. I I, you know, I built the original TASERs in a garage. I feel like I got my hands around this. But this software thing, you know, turns out the guy I'd hired is probably, you know, not the right not the right guy. We were having technical issues. And frankly, I was struggling to wrap my head around, like, how how do we staff and grow this business? This is pretty new to me. And so I asked Hadi if he would join the board and he came on. He was effectively... He was a board member but he was really my part time CTO for about five years where he helped me sort through, get the right business and get the right team in place. We moved like we were originally building our own data center that we were gonna manage for our customers. We had a near catastrophic outage where we nearly lost all our customer data and, you know, Hadi was like, hey, man, like there's plenty of hard things to do in this world. Like trying to figure out how to run your own data center is not one that's worth the squeeze. We moved over to the cloud with AWS and then with Azure. And, yeah, so I I like to say Hadi saved the business because he came in. He was the guy who helped me navigate how to build a software business from scratch inside a weapon business. And by the way, as we were doing this, our shareholders thought I'd lost my mind. They're like, Rick, you're trying to turn a weapon company into a software company. I guess I was... Many entrepreneurs, you don't realize what a crazy idea that was and and Hadi was the guy who helped me do it. Jason Calacanis (00:19:36): Did he stay on your board? Rick Smith (00:19:37): Yeah. He's still on my board. Jason Calacanis (00:19:39): Amazing. I mean, the the stock price, you're you're like a $3,540,000,000,000 dollar market cap company today. He must have done well. I'm gonna say that. Rick Smith (00:19:47): Yeah. Yeah. I mean and and Hadi also is the guy who pushed for us to change the name from Taser to something else, which became Axon. Because... And and look, at the time that was hard, we're really invested in our brand. We're proud of the Taser. We didn't wanna feel like we're retreating. And Hadi's point was like, hey, man. The TASER is a kind of a... It's a sledgehammer brand. It means electric weapon to people and you do a lot more than that. And so, you know, he he helped me think that through and and he was right. You know? Now we have the... The TASER is a small part of the business. It's important, but, you know, it's... We have an expansive business. Now we manage, I think, more video every day than YouTube. Now they have a lot more viewers, but we have over a million police officers uploading two hours of video, you know, every day from one of these body cameras. So we have a ton of content and, of course, it's gotta be securely managed and shared and there's been a lot of complexity. And, of course, I've got a great team in place now, thanks to Hadi coming in and and sort of helping me learn this business and rebuild the plane while we were flying. Jason Calacanis (00:20:46): Good. Go, hottie. Rick Smith (00:20:47): Yeah. So there's one other thing that happened in there. So while we were defending ourselves in all the litigation, we also went on offense and we created the body camera. And the reason we created the body camera was, you know what? The only way to defend ourselves... And look, our customers were being accused of doing horrible things with taser weapons. Jason Calacanis (00:21:05): Remember I police officers. Rick Smith (00:21:06): Right? Yep. Yeah. Police officers. I was co defending a case in Northern California where somebody died in police custody. It was a young... It was a 40 year old man with a twenty year methamphetamine problem and he was in really bad shape. And I remember the police officers telling me as we're watching the trial, the family kept putting up pictures of his high school graduation and the officers looked at me and they said, that's not the human being I saw the night I went to that house. I saw somebody who was literally like out of The Exorcist movie. This cop told me he'd been a cop for twenty six years, had never been afraid in his career until the animalistic rage he had to deal with in this person who was, you know, had had overdosed on meth, but that never came across to the jury. And in that moment, I said, my god. We have to record what you see because, like, when police officers describe things, they have to be very professional. In this case, it was, you know, when mister Heston did this or that, very professional. The family that's suing the police, they would use very emotional, colorful language. And I was like, guys, you're getting your you're getting your asses kicked, frankly. You need to tell your story with more passion. And they said, Rick, we don't get to do that. Like, we work for the government. If if we get caught in one half truth, that can be the end of our career. And that's when we realized, like, we need to record this so that you can show people what it is that you saw, what it is you did rather than having to try to explain it. Weren't there body cam companies already at the time? Did they exist? Was this concept novel? The concept was new. I mean, you did have GoPro with like consumer cameras, so we certainly didn't invent the cameras. But we... Again, a quick detour. We were building the first police body camera and then the employee that was building it actually quit in the middle of the night and launched the product a week later. Turns out he was actually funding it with his stock options to build it against us. That's another bit of drama. Rick Smith (00:22:57): But, yes, we we were building the industry's first body camera. We ultimately, you know, made peace and we acquired that company back into the fold down the road. But but that's what that's what led to the eventual explode. The reason that we're a, I don't know, a $30,000,000,000 company today up from a couple 100,000,000 is because of the body camera. And I'll tell you, when we launched the body camera, Jason Calacanis (00:23:19): police Rick Smith (00:23:19): didn't wanna wear it. We had seven years of miserable failure where cops told us there's... You know, this is Big Brother. They're worried that their supervisor's gonna nitpick them. I mean, look, change is hard. Right? People find a lot of reasons like to be afraid of of of of new things, but we just believed in our in our soul. Guys, you need to be able to show people what you do. You're being accused of all sorts of awful stuff And we made a double bet. Not only do we bet on body cameras, but we bet on the cloud because we realized the only way this would ever scale is if we put these videos into cloud infrastructure. Otherwise, you have 18,000 departments all trying to figure out how to run video servers securely. But this creates a ton of Jason Calacanis (00:23:59): liability for these police forces, doesn't it? Like now, all of a sudden, they're being held accountable. By the way, I love watching body cam videos. The cop did something wrong, the criminal did something wrong. I mean, there's always just drama to these stories. Yeah. But I've got to imagine a lot of these police officers, because there's a lot of these stories, that they're using the body cam or they don't they don't realize the body cam's on and they get themselves in trouble. And so isn't there a bit of a liability issue, and how do you end up selling your customer on putting themselves at risk, or do they view it as a double edged sword that they're... It's also for their own safety, their own protection, and for winning cases? Rick Smith (00:24:32): So you are articulating the exact concern people had up front. That's why they didn't wanna wear it because they had that perception. However, once... Actually, a police union leader told me... Famously said, no cop wants to wear a body camera until they've worn one for ninety days, and then they will not go on patrol without it. Because what you don't realize, police are arresting criminals all the time, and criminals have no compunction about lying about what happened. The number of false allegations are incredible. I'm gonna give you one example. I'm on a ride along with a comp and penis, and this is in the early days of body cameras. And I said, how's it going? He said, well, I didn't like this but let me tell you what happened to me last week. I was arresting a prostitute. She was basically more than half naked. She was high on some sort of drugs and as I put her into the patrol cars, I'm driving her into the station, she starts screaming at him, I'm gonna say you raped me. I'm gonna say you raped me unless you hit me out of the car right now. And he said, ma'am, I just wanna let you know this is a body camera. I've been recording this entire interaction. You're free to say whatever you want, but it's all being recorded. And he said her demeanor changed completely. She calmed down. And he said, now imagine what I would have gone through if I didn't have a body camera. If I had a woman accusing me of raping her and it turned into a he said, she said, like, that could be a career ending allegation with no way to disprove it. So that was that was like a microcosm but the moment that things flipped was the shooting of Michael Brown in Ferguson, Missouri. Remember Ferguson? Jason Calacanis (00:25:58): Yeah. Rick Smith (00:25:59): White officer, black subject. Now, Michael Brown was unarmed but he was significantly larger than officer Wilson. And according to officer Wilson, they were fighting over the gun. Like, the officer... You know, an officer brings a gun to every fight they get in. And once they're fighting over the gun, you know, he's justified to defend himself. But if you remember the stories, the family was saying things like, remember, hands up, don't shoot, that that Michael Brown was trying to surrender. If that's true, then that was a cold blooded murder. But if you listen to the officer, he says, hey. I was being attacked. In fact, I think he had a broken eye, a broken bone above his eye. The subsequent review ended up showing that the officer was largely correct, but you couldn't prove it. And it was out... After that case, Michael Brown's cam... Family said, we want body cameras, and the police union said, you know what? We want them because we at least want the world to see what's happening. And now as I sit here today, what's interesting, some of these civil liberties groups that were big proponents of body cameras are now saying that they're turning against them. They're saying they're broken because they're not finding all these bad cops, that there's something wrong with the body cameras. I have a different point of view and that is you have to accept the possibility that the vast majority of cops do a good job and they're falsely accused. And I think that's what body cameras have proven. Jason Calacanis (00:27:19): And so you get out there, the market starts moving, and I'm assuming it just becomes de facto. Right? I mean, all over the country at this point. I mean, maybe you can just share a little bit about the scale of the business today. Rick Smith (00:27:30): Oh, yeah. Yeah. Once once Ferguson happened, then everybody needed body cameras and they needed them fast. And that's where our bet on the cloud made a big... Remember back in the day, like, you know, in 2010, cloud was relatively new to government and they they they had this perception, well, if it's here and it's sitting on my computer, it's safe because it's here in the room with me. Right? I can keep eyes on it. But that's not true. In cybersecurity, there could be Chinese hackers, you know, in the server in my building. No problem. It comes down to the technology and the stack and the people you've got. And so, like, from a first principles, we knew the cloud could be safer than your average police department and we could scale it. And so because of the urgency after Michael Brown, then it just really took off. And so today, virtually, I think every major police department now wears body cameras and we have... The vast majority are on our system, I think partly because we are first, but also because we tend to be we're sort of maniacally mission driven. And I know that always sounds a little bit cheesy, but like we have the luxury of choosing what problems we wanna solve. And so we work on things that are gonna make a difference that we're excited about and that leads to different product outcomes than companies that are just purely profit motivated. Maybe you could tell us a little bit about what's gone on recently with some of the public sentiment around monitoring. So there's this company, Flock, that's been installing cameras in cities, and they're starting to get these city councils to reject the cameras. And there's this concern about the development of effectively a surveillance state and that government agencies, police forces, getting all of this monitoring technology creates a bigger, more powerful state that's monitoring us all the time. Rick Smith (00:29:20): No citizens wanna have that. And, obviously, there's the public safety argument, but maybe you could just kind of frame up what's going on with public sentiment right now and these issues. Well, I I think this is part of a larger concern about AI in general and the proliferation of cameras and sensors. And look, it's not unreasonable. Like, I don't think any of us want to live in China, meaning, you know, a surveillance state where every citizen is tracked everywhere they go. However, I think there's gotta be some nuance here. We can't go back to United States as it existed in the nineteen fifties when there weren't cameras everywhere. The fact is there are cameras everywhere. There's more cameras than people. You know, you and I probably have four cameras just on our cell phones plus, you know, maybe a dozen in our house plus all the business cameras. So really what this comes down to is how we think about data governance. Like how should society, under what circumstances should we share those camera feeds to the government? How should they use that? I think, in general, we try to distill things down to simple, you know, principles about, okay, what would we be proud that we've built? Like, what would be good for society? And if we build that, it will be durable. And so in the example of cameras, look, we build license plate reading cameras too. I think we've been pretty thoughtful about the the the security controls we put in place to try to avoid some of the issues you've seen. What people are really upset about are things like when a police officer can go in and do searches on their, you know, ex girlfriend. Like, those sorts of things are morally offensive to folks. Or if you could track every American everywhere they go, like, we don't want that. But, like, tracking a stolen vehicle, you know, finding, being able to look up license plates that are around the the the crime scene of a violent crime. Like, people agree that those are reasonable use cases. And even the critics, like Ben Jordan has been a very thoughtful critic. I think he kinda started this. Rick Smith (00:31:17): He will tell you if you listen to him. He's not saying to get rid of this technology. We just need good guardrails and we need safeguards. And so I'm a big proponent. By the time this webcast actually hits, I think, you know, we'll be after the election and we'll start to see some some movement in federal regulation. I'm a big supporter of what senator Hawley is doing to introduce guidelines and oversight so that we can get the benefit of this... These technologies to fight crime, but safeguards to prevent them from tracking everyday Americans. Jason Calacanis (00:31:47): Do you think that people get that rationally? Because I've I've noticed some things you can kinda get people to rationalize and you can understand them and other things people just have a very acute emotional response, and they're like icky, yucky. I don't wanna have anything to do with that. I think Ring did that Super Bowl ad, and the the negative sentiment around the Super Bowl ad being it's so creepy that all these cameras are monitoring everyone all over the neighborhood all the time is what really triggered a lot of people. And I think there were stories about flock where these cameras were being used by city employees to look at people when they weren't supposed to be. So you could argue, yes, let's put in the guardrails, but the general notion that this sort of technology exists, this sort of power exists, the the the sort of privacy infiltration intrusion exists makes people feel really uncomfortable with it. How do you kind of think about changing that sentiment to being one of rational and guardrails and away from the sort of big emotional response everyone's having? Rick Smith (00:32:43): Yeah. Jason Calacanis (00:32:43): Well, Rick Smith (00:32:44): I think part of that's just an adjustment as as society moves forward. Like, look, plenty of people still go... They they may say, boy, that made me uncomfortable, but they go buy Ring cameras specifically because Ring has some of the best technology for being able to protect your home or if you need to share videos with police because you had a crime at your house. And so I think there is a little bit of back and forth, which is is normal. Like, this is democracy. Like, as you move forward, people aren't gonna agree on every topic. But over time, I think, you know, we find middle ground. I don't think it's reasonable. I don't think we're to end up with, like, making doorbell cameras illegal. Right? But I think Ring likely learned from that incident. They've they've put really good safeguards in place. In fact, we have we have a partnership with Ring where we're both very focused on how do we enable homeowners to share Ring camera video if there's a crime committed with the police but actually make it really hard for people to enable... Like, we don't enable police to just go out and randomly, you know, canvas those videos. There's a ton of privacy work that goes in so that people know these are my cameras. I control how they're used. And... But if I, you know... I I actually had a a car stolen from my house years ago and it took me days. I had to get a technician to come download the video from this like, you know, homegrown camera system. I couldn't get it to the police for days. I have Ring now because I do wanna be able to share it if something like that happens. So I I think it it is also a matter of just... Yes. Not everybody's gonna agree with the guardrails, but I think policymakers can't just... You know, we have to find the reasonable middle ground. We've gotta find reasonable public policy, and we've already seen that. Think, again, I was really impressed with senator Hawley's bill. It's very rational. It's got criminal penalties. Rick Smith (00:34:33): If police officers individually misuse this for personal purposes, I believe there's criminal and civil penalties. And then there's going to be safeguards for manufacturers like us and FLoC that are going to require that before you can run searches, you've gotta have viable case codes that we know this is a legitimate case that's somewhere in your law enforcement system. There's two key systems where you've got to have collaboration before you're running searches. So if you're searching for your ex, you're gonna have to find another officer who's willing to put their career at risk before you can do that. Right? Those sorts of safeguards, I think, will get the 90% of people that are rationally paying attention to this too, but you're not gonna win a 100%. Sure. There are gonna be some people that are just gonna have a fear of this and and... But I think, you know, I've been around this long enough to see those things subside when you when you get good rational safeguards in place. Jason Calacanis (00:35:25): So, I mean, you guys start with the taser handheld device, reduce the use of guns in in policing, move to the body cam, and now you guys have this framing, I believe, on being the operating system for public safety. What else does that encompass? So is it similar to Flock's business and maybe help explain some of the other products that come out now and in time to realize that mission? Rick Smith (00:35:49): Yeah. So we... Our mission is to protect life and we we chose those two words meaning we focus on violence as a problem that's worth solving. And that means with a taser, our goal is how do we reduce the number of times police actually have to shoot and kill someone? With a body camera, it's how do we reduce the risk of police using too much force and how do we protect them when they're doing this job that is dangerous and risky so that they don't have to worry about being falsely accused of things. And then we persist that all the way through. We're partnered with Skydio on drones. So in fact, we recently will have become the largest investor in America's leading drone company. So if you don't know Skydio, they're the guys who build these robotic autonomous docks where a a drone can now be flown from off a fire station anywhere in a city and you can have a drone on scene in a matter of seconds. This is reducing the number of times police have to take resources to go, you know, to alarm calls, so it allows them to focus on bigger calls. And when there's big events, they're able to get a drone on scene sometimes before the 911 operator has even finished entering the call for service. So that's improving the service to the community. Now, again, drones are also an area where people would say, well, there are things like, how are these being used? How do we have safeguards to know the police aren't, you know, using these in ways that the public wouldn't want them to? And so Skydio, together with us, we've developed controls. For example, agencies can share their mission profiles with the public. So if the public has concerns, they can see how they're being used. And most agencies have policies where they're not just flying drones around on on patrol missions. They very specifically fly them only to the site when they've been called where somebody is calling for help and you get a drone there quickly, that can help get help you see what's happening. And in some cases, they've even flown a drone down and been able to distract or we've had people surrender to drones. Rick Smith (00:37:50): So I think the whole idea is across the board of all the things we do, we look for how do we connect these devices together in a way that's going to make us all safer, but also acknowledge that, yes, there are risks of abuse and we should build this in ways that address those risks. We're not gonna win everybody's... You know, not everybody's going to agree on everything, but we've so far been able to get to a point where we're finding that right balance so that we're using these things to make the world safer and protect privacy and find the right balance along the way. Jason Calacanis (00:38:23): You know, I think there's this great debate on how much safety and at what cost that I think is what really triggers a lot of people that the benefit to them individually of more safety doesn't feel felt as acutely as the risk or the cost to their privacy or their personal space as Orwellian idea that the state has so much power that the government, that the policing force has so much power that they can effectively... If they chose to, there may be guardrails. But if they chose to, they now have such supremacy over the citizens. And it is Orwellian idea that now the state can determine, hey. I don't like the the speech that you're using or I don't like whatever it might be. There's all these reasons why people can feel like there's an infringement of that power of force upon them. It's almost like how far do you take it? Like, the movie Minority Report, I think, did a good job exploring this where it's like at what point do you become predictive with AI of crime happening and then you arrest people before they do the crime and, you know, everyone's kind of fantastical ideas become, is that really worth the risk? Like, do I really wanna take on that level of cost to my individual liberties to have, quote, that much more safety? I And think that seems to be the great debate people seem to be having right now. Is that is that a fair characterization or do you think it's a little bit misguided? Rick Smith (00:39:47): No. No. I think it's a fair debate and that is the right debate to be having. And I think... But this is hard work. Right? Like, it's it's finding the balance. And what's interesting, you will find the people who most want these sorts of technologies come from the poorest neighborhoods that have the highest crime rates. Paradoxically, those are the ones that, you know, people say, well, we worry about over policing. Jason Calacanis (00:40:10): Right. Rick Smith (00:40:10): But when you when you actually go out, you know, frankly, a lot of the most concerns are coming from wealthy neighborhoods where this is more theoretical. But when you talk to people that are dealing with gun violence every day in their cities, they cheer when the police show up, and they're the ones who wanna have more of this technology so there's deterrence. I mean, ultimately, I would say this. In America, sometimes we we we have these simplistic notions. Like, you know, frankly, in the political spectrum sometimes there's just lock everybody up or no. No. No. Like, abolish the police. Like, come on. Like, neither of those are the right solution. I think the right solution is how do we deploy technology so we deter people from making bad decisions in the first place. Like, the best deterrence to criminal behavior is not long sentences. It's a high probability that you will get caught and prosecuted. And then the question is how do we then balance that as well against making sure that we're not building technology that can be used to track everyday people? But those are interesting those are interesting techno ethical problems to deal with. Right? How do we build the tech to to meet the ethical bar to make the right trade offs? Jason Calacanis (00:41:17): You're right. I don't live or work in neighborhoods where I'm experiencing a lot of violent crime. I am driving through San Francisco, and I got three speeding tickets. I'm like, get rid of those damn cameras. You know? Like, my reaction is, why are these cameras here? It's what this guy Rob Henderson calls luxury beliefs. I think there was an incident in... I... And I have this in my notes. In June 2022, you had some members of your advisory board who quit in protest after you guys announced plans to develop a TASER equipped surveillance drone that you were designing to stop school shootings. And I think the board had voted against the project due to ethical concerns and whatnot and privacy concerns. Can you tell us a little bit about kind of that incident? What what you've learned from it and does that project still continue? Rick Smith (00:41:59): Yes. That project is continuing and that's that's why they quit. That was... Look. Life can be challenging at times. I was very disappointed. We we set up an AI ethics board to give us feedback, frankly, not from pro police people, but from civil liberties groups that are concerned about policing. Right? And that's been a very useful function. That's one of the reasons we've got, I think, great safeguards in how we built ALPR and other technologies. Now on this case, we had been working with them for about a year on the idea that we could have a taser capable drone to be used in extreme circumstances, like a school shooting was the the incident there. But today, for example, if you have a person with a gun show up in a building anywhere in America, do you know how we stop them? Jason Calacanis (00:42:47): We gotta wait for the police with the gun? Rick Smith (00:42:49): Yeah. We send in more people with guns and they have a gunfight. Yeah. Yeah. This is the Wild West, guys. Like, is that really the best we can do as a society? And so what we're saying is rather than waiting and sending a person with gun to have more bullets flying, we could send in a drone or a robot armed with a nonlethal weapon. This is a key distinction. Like, you'll never get a cop that will take a nonlethal weapon up against somebody with a gun. But if we can send in a small drone or robot, then the the... Everything shifts. They're like, oh, wait a minute. Now I can use nonlethal force. Now we can argue whether or not the criminal deserves to die, but even there, like, anytime you have more bullets introduced, there's innocent bystanders get killed all the time accidentally. And so I continue to believe, and we are doing r and d on this, that using nonlethal force safely deployed from a distance via drone or robot is in everybody's best interest compared to, you know, having more gunfights in society. Now because the the way that went down, frankly, I think this was post George Floyd, some of our advisers were worried about getting canceled over this issue. I mean, many of them worked in universities and they were already being accused of being pro police. And so I think there was some personal dynamics. Many of the people on the board privately agreed with me that, like, you're right, Rick. This is a this is a better solution than what we have today with sending in cops with body armor and assault rifles, but it was too politically risky and it and it blew up. But I'll tell you one thing I'm proud of. We didn't give up. Many companies have now canceled their ethics boards. We dug in. We reconstituted. We still have. It's been rebranded as our Equity and Ethics Advisory Council. And frankly, it now has more black and brown voices on it where previously it was more academically focused. Like, if you wanna talk about the concerns of over policing, it is primarily from underrepresented, you know, communities. And one of the criticisms we had gotten from... Rick Smith (00:44:41): In that whole process was that we didn't have the right people in the room. If you wanna talk about, again, the concerns of over policing, it it should be from from communities that are most affected. And so you live and you learn. We've recalibrated, but we've continued to bring in, you know, people who have critical views of policing because we think those are important for us to understand their concerns. And by doing it early, we actually learn in many cases, we can build safeguards into the product if you listen and you do it upfront. It's much better for us to do that and hear the critical voices early in design process rather than after we've launched it because then all we can do is sort of argue about things. We... We've lost the ability to make significant design changes. Jason Calacanis (00:45:24): Let's just talk about the future. Ten years from now, I think there's five companies launching humanoid like robots for commercial sale in the next twelve to eighteen months that are gonna be available here in The US. 10 to $30,000 price ranges have been kind of talked about. Do you think the future of policing involves humanoid robots, other types of robots, and drones? Give us a sense of a decade from now or fifteen years from now what local community policing looks like with all this technology that's coming to market? Rick Smith (00:45:56): Yep. Well, first I would say policing is still fundamentally a human job. Any decisions about using force on another person will be made by humans and that's a that's a bright line for us. So even with the TASER drone you and I talked about earlier, part of what we learned from the concern was people are worried about misuse, abuse, how these things will be used. So any of the robotic systems we're involved in will not only have required human oversight, but we're building multi key processes. So, for example, you could set it up so that before any officer could operate even a nonlethal weapon from a drone or robot, we can set it up so that there's required real time approval from an administrator. So we're actually gonna be building the least abusable technology in the history of of policing. Like today, you give a cop a gun, they walk out the door. You have no control over what they do with it. You can prosecute them later. These robotic systems will give us the ability to have institutional decision making with multiple parties in real time, which I think will lead to far less, you know, mistakes, less concerns about abuse. And I do believe both humanoids... I think drones will be bigger faster. Humanoids are coming as well. But, again, that's why we we invested in Skydio. We we bought almost half the company. We we wanted to buy about as much as we could because we're big believers that there's gonna be millions of drones in the next few years deployed in The US. But we also actually felt in this case, was better for us to leave it as a... As an independent company that could move at startup speed and continue to raise and spend capital in ways that maybe weren't constrained by being part of a public company. And yet at the same time, we've secured the the exclusive rights so we will be the exclusive channel into the markets that we care about because we believe that is absolutely gonna be one of the biggest parts of the future is drones and robots arriving on scene way before people, you know, have an opportunity to get there. Rick Smith (00:47:50): And the whole idea is to just let's understand what's happening. Let's let's make sure we're making the best decisions possible. And the idea is to keep everybody as safe as we can. Jason Calacanis (00:47:59): How do citizens feel like they can maintain their individual liberties from being overwhelmed by a state that is equipped with this much technology? I think that's really where I react personally to think about as a more of a libertarian. I'm a big proponent of the role of government being public safety, so let me be clear on this. But this idea that you're creating a significant concentration of this extraordinary power, and it's hard for the citizens to be able to ultimately protect themselves against a government that decides to overwhelm voices and individuals at some point in the future. Rick Smith (00:48:34): Just gotta do is take a step back and look in the world as it exists today. So let's imagine, David, that police have got a tip that there's a dangerous felon in your house. This has happened. Right? We've all heard of cases where police go to the wrong house and they're doing an entry. So today, the way that works, like if they believe that you're a dangerous felon, they may come through the door in your house and you're gonna be dealing with multiple officers that are suited up with body armor with lethal weapons in their hands who are gonna have to make a life or death decision instantaneously while their own adrenaline is surging. Right? Human beings don't make good decisions under the fight or flight. So the fact is the government already has a monopoly on the legal use of force, and it's almost and every one of those officers has lethal force. And I will tell you, if they feel their life is at risk, the thing in their hand will be a gun. By comparison, if those police are going to come into your house, imagine a future where if they do have to do this mission, and again, we can debate about under what conditions they should do it, now they're gonna be sending in a drone or a robot. So the operator is going to be a team of people, not just one. It's not gonna be a person who's in the fight or flight response afraid for their own safety shaking with their finger on the trigger. And if they make a mistake, you're gonna get hit with a taser or a pepper spray or some non lethal weapon. And, oh, by the way, the whole thing will be recorded because to even operate these things, you have to have camera systems on them. Many police shootings today are not recorded. And so I think it just comes back to how do we... You know, we we just need to sort of take a step back and understand how the job is done today and how we can do it in the future that is safer for everybody and then answer legitimate questions about what are the controls in place. Things like multi key authorization. We will work with our customers to push hard that every one of them has an oversight function. Rick Smith (00:50:29): So anytime one of these robotic systems is used, that there's independent civilian oversight and review. So I think, again, this just comes down to it's not an unreasonable concern. These things could be misused. Right. However, we also don't wanna... I don't wanna live in a world where everybody else has robotics and AI and the police are showing up in a '74 Chevy, you know, with an old radio. Like, they're gonna need enough tech to keep up with the rest of us and then the laws and regulations and oversight are gonna have to evolve, you to make sure that we are controlling the government as the people and that we've got a good judiciary and good balance of power so that they can't do abusive things without, you know, being held accountable. Jason Calacanis (00:51:12): And what's your view on the shifting political landscape, the rise of a DSA political class today that's calling for defunding the police, and what do you think happens to communities and cities over the next couple of years if and as more of that voice becomes elected? Rick Smith (00:51:31): Well, if you actually defund the police, you know, we'll... We will get some social experiments. I can tell you, you don't need an experiment to show what would happen. It will be catastrophic. But, you know, democracies recover. And I'll give you an example. And I think it was in 1968, the police in Montreal, Canada went on strike for no other reason. It was a simple... It was overpay. There was no, you know, there was no George Floyd type situation. This was just a labor relations strike. And looking back on it, that is now known as the night of terror because criminals heard the police were on strike and the city went crazy. In fact, Steven Pinker, the Harvard psychologist who's Yeah. Sort of famously both liberal but also very rational. He wrote Better Angels of Our Nature and this is his example on like you need a functional police force because it is the the glue that that holds society together so we have rules that we can all trust we're going to abide by. And so I hope we don't see major examples of that. We started to see some of that, frankly, with some states had decriminalized shoplifting, as you recall, in the post George Floyd, and that led to catastrophic consequences where you Jason Calacanis (00:52:39): saw major San Francisco got abandoned. I've seen it myself. Yeah. Rick Smith (00:52:44): Yeah. And then with that, you get the jobs flee. You get these, you know, deserts where there's no economic activity because it's just not safe for people to do it. The business models implode. Now I think in your example, I think San Francisco has already begun to swing the other direction and take corrective action. And so I I try to stay out of politics too much. I think, you know, things things will swing one way or the other, but we have corrective mechanisms that over time will will kick in. Jason Calacanis (00:53:11): And I think non lethality is a is a great mission. I think public safety is critical to the underwriting of all of our other social contracts. Without good public safety, none of the other social contracts work and the systems don't work and so I think obviously it's an important mission and important work you do. Congrats on on the business, on the progress, on the Skydio investment. Obviously, there's a lot of, I think, social challenges ahead here with this big debate that's going on right now on the limits of that and the limits of technology. Rick Smith (00:53:42): Well, I'll tell you as well, like, you know, there's there's a lot of uncertainty right now. You know, The Economist, I think four months ago had a cover that, you know, the AI jobs apocalypse. And then Totally. A couple months later, was the, hey. Wait a minute. No. AI is making millions of jobs. Like, people don't know what to think and we are at this point where the acceleration of technology is leading to massive amounts of uncertainty. And what I tell our customers is like, guys, we need you to stay strong. Like, policing is... Might be the glue that needs to hold society together. Hopefully, we don't see the sorts of things we're seeing in France right now and the sort of social upheaval. But god forbid, if we do, we need the men and women of law enforcement to be ready to stand up and and help us keep order as we get through to what... I'm I'm a huge optimist. I think ten, twenty years from now is gonna be a near utopian society. Again, for... Maybe I'm a little out over my skis, but I think technology is going to cure many diseases, many ills. I think we're gonna see, you know, Elon's idea of universal high income will be fantastic, but we may have some difficult moments as we get through the And our view... Our role at Axon is like how do we arm the police for that in a way we'll look back up and we'll be proud of the way that we did it to help them do this the right way. Now, I mean, it's gonna be perfect, but let's put some good controls in place and and help make people more comfortable that, you know, we're gonna we're gonna get through this together okay. Yeah. Well, Rick, I really appreciate you taking the time. I'm glad we got Jason Calacanis (00:55:09): to finally do this. Thanks for joining us on the all in interview. It's been great. Rick Smith (00:55:12): Been a lot of fun. Anytime. Jason Calacanis (00:55:14): Alright, besties. I think that was another epic discussion. People love the Internet. I could hear him talk for hours. Absolutely. We crushed Rick Smith (00:55:24): your questions in a minute. Jason Calacanis (00:55:25): We are giving people ground truth data to underwrite your own opinion. What'd you guys think? That was fun. That was great.

本集资源与出处