文稿来自 All-In 官网(allin.com)发布的官方 Transcript,说话人按官网分轨数据标注,个别段落可能张冠李戴。
Jason Calacanis (00:00:00): Alright, everybody. We're laughing it up here. It's the All In podcast. Apparently, slow news weeks continue. Once again, we struggle to put together a docket, but we're gonna try to get something together here, Sachs. I don't know what's in the news. Maybe you have a SaaS corner for us? Any new hotness drop in the SaaS world or no?
David Sacks (00:00:19): Yeah. Benioff rolled out a new reporting feature. I'm only top of docket material.
Jason Calacanis (00:00:24): Alright. That is top of docket. You're right. You're right. Freiburg, of course, is here cackling. He's in a good mood, but I understand you almost died in the last week. What were you? In the hospital? You had the flu?
David Friedberg (00:00:34): I got the pneumonia. Not good. Very bad. Very bad. I do not wish it upon anyone. Knocked out in the hospital. Everyone, stay safe.
Jason Calacanis (00:00:42): Alright. Well, every... I I saw everybody with their social media wish... Well wishing you. And, of course, Chamath Bhaihapatea is here, and it's a deep pull for Chamath today, a deep pull from the closet. My lord. I haven't seen that sweater since Biden was in office.
Chamath Palihapitiya (00:01:00): It's a nice ribbed cashmere mock turtleneck.
Jason Calacanis (00:01:03): Okay. Ribbed for Chamath's pleasure.
David Friedberg (00:01:05): Ribbed for Chamad's pleasure. Alright.
Jason Calacanis (00:01:09): Listen.
David Sacks (00:01:09): I thought I was supposed to be ribbed for her pleasure.
Jason Calacanis (00:01:11): It's for her pleasure. But it's Chamad. It's all for it's all for Chamad's pleasure. It's always
David Friedberg (00:01:15): for his pleasure.
Jason Calacanis (00:01:16): Absolutely. That that's that's who he is. Alright. Listen. Jensen is out as NVIDIA's CEO after an insane series of events that happened in the past week. All of this played out in just six days starting Friday, November 6, and obviously record on Thursdays, which would be November 12. Here's where things stand as of the taping of this episode. NVIDIA's CFO will serve as the interim CEO. The board's looking for a new chief executive. Nvidia reports earnings next Tuesday, critical moment for the company, and the stock has been crushed down 15% in the last week, which is hundreds of billions of dollars. Here's the timeline that led to Jensen's ouster. Last Friday, November 6, right after the midterms, interesting timing, The New York Times published a report claiming a Chinese businesswoman who had a close relationship with Jensen was actually a CCP spy, a Chinese Communist Party spy. The woman is named Alice Wang. No relation to Jensen. They just happen to share the same last name. We'll call her Alice for the rest of this discussion. She's an executive at a Singapore based company called Mega Speed. They build data centers in Asia. They rent compute to companies including Chinese ones like Alibaba. According to the information, their relationship, Jensen's and Alice's helped facilitate 7,500,000,000 in chips to Chinese companies since 2023. The New York Times article was based on a leaked intelligence memo that identified Alice as a Chinese spy. No one knows who leaked it. On Sunday, November 8, Jensen sent a company wide email admitting he had an affair and that the board would be investigating Wednesday. The New York Times reported Jensen had a second affair with a direct report. There's reports of a third potential affair. Let's put all that aside and focus on his resignation, which came after thirty three years as CEO. Important caveat. This story has been hiding in plain sight for well over a year. The New York Times first mentioned Alice's relationship with Jensen back in October 2025, not this October 2026, thirteen months ago. They published a follow-up last month, NVIDIA chief seen as target of Chinese spy plot.
Jason Calacanis (00:03:41): Culper Research, spelled c u l p e r, is a hedge fund that put a short on NVIDIA according to their tweet storm six months ago. They published their thesis, which was based on NVIDIA underselling its reliance on China for chip sales. They even mentioned Megaspeed by name in that tweet storm, which you can see on the screen right here. This is a disaster for the White House. There are reports of finger pointing as officials try to figure out why mega speed was left off the export control list after these New York Times articles. And we'll get into more export control issues later. Okay, Sachs. We're dealing with partial information here. This is a breaking news story, caveat, caveat, disclaimer, disclaimer. But let me ask you a simple question. Given the New York Times reporting, what's your take on what they've released to date?
David Sacks (00:04:33): First of all, let me just say that I think this is a tragic situation. Okay? It's tragic for Jensen and his family and for Nvidia and its employees. And I would say it's tragic for The United States Of America because Jensen is one of the key reasons why we have a major advantage in AI accelerator chips and GPUs. And that in turn is one of our key advantages in the AI or superintelligence race. In fact, Jensen made such a good chip that many people in Washington wanted to export control that. I think people kinda forget. Jensen's been working on GPUs for over three decades and he believed in this technology and this architecture when everyone else was making CPUs and his company almost went out of business multiple times. It was his vision that created the GPU which ended up being the key chip that's used in AI. And it's the fact that NVIDIA is so far ahead of everybody else that is what gives The United States a key advantage in this thing we call the the AI or superintelligence race. So I think this is a tragic situation and I think that what's happened here is, I mean, clearly it's not a great situation for all the individuals involved. I don't think this redounds to the benefit of The United States either. And it's very unfortunate that this whole situation could not have been resolved in a different way. Now, let's talk about the story that's come out. I think it's pretty clear that there were two ops here. So one op is whatever Alice Wong was doing with or without the Chinese Communist Party. There may have been smuggling involved. We don't know. There is an investigation going on, and there should be an investigation. We should get all the facts there. We've talked on this podcast about how we do not believe that leading anti ships should go to China, and if there's any smuggling going on, that that is wrong, and that it should be stopped, and the government should crack down on that. So that investigation should continue, we should get all the facts there, and we should find out what actually happened. So that is one op is whatever Alice Wong was doing, again, with or without the CCP. But however, there's also a second op here. And that second op began when somebody or multiple people leaked a highly classified memo or the contents of it to the New York Times.
David Sacks (00:07:06): I think it's really important to understand that that's a crime. I mean, leaking classified intelligence is a crime, and many people have been prosecuted for it. In fact, we had multiple former presidents and current presidents, president Trump and president Biden. Their homes were raided because supposedly, they had classified documents in their possession. Remember that? There was a raid on Mar A Lago. There was a raid on Joe Biden's garage, and they found the Mike Pence got caught.
Jason Calacanis (00:07:33): And it
David Sacks (00:07:33): happens
Jason Calacanis (00:07:34): to everybody, it seems.
David Sacks (00:07:35): Yeah. Well, I don't know if it happens to everybody, but it's it's a serious crime. And, you know, because of that fact, I don't believe that the New York Times just got this by overhearing people talking about it at a bar. Somebody made the calculated decision that they're willing to risk going to jail, they're willing to risk committing a crime to let The New York Times know about this story. And so I have a series of questions about that. So number one is first, who did that and why? What was their motivation? Why did they feel so strongly about taking Jensen down, that had to be at least a part of their motive, that they're willing to break the law. And I do think it makes sense for there to be an investigation opened into this leak as there have been with many other classified leaks. I don't know why there hasn't been an investigation opened as far as we know into this. So that would be question number one is why this leak?
Jason Calacanis (00:08:29): And the New York Times has given a clue there. Obviously, Rubio was leading this investigation, briefed president Trump on it, and the New York Times attributed the story, the spy part of the story anonymously to quote, people briefed on the surveillance. I'll leave that Yes.
David Sacks (00:08:43): But just... Let's be very clear here. I don't I don't really like you using Marco Rubio's name there, but because he's national security adviser. If there was a classified memo, then obviously it would be done under this... His revision as the head of
Jason Calacanis (00:08:56): the Yeah. I'm not insinuating he's a leak, but it's somebody he may briefed.
David Sacks (00:08:59): Kinda... You... Okay. When the when the New York Times says people briefed on the matter, that is an extremely vague and broad terminology. And it could be very low level officials who did this. And when the New York Times even uses the word official, that doesn't mean they're a senior person in an administration. They could be very very low level. And it could also be the case that their careers, which is to say nonpolitical appointees, that just because they're serving in the executive branch of the Trump administration doesn't mean that they are Trump officials. So look, we don't know who committed the leak. All we know is they committed a crime. And I I do think that we should be asking the question, who did that and why? Okay. So that's sort of bucket number one of questions. Bucket number two is around the failure to give the defensive briefing. If the national security state is worried that Jensen is in possession of national security secrets and might leak them to someone who they suspect is a spy, why wouldn't you go to him right away and tell him, hey, you have this problem, don't talk to this person. Apparently that didn't happen and it does sound like that is some sort of standard operating procedure. Let me give you an example. So we have the case of Eric Swalwell. Okay, so Eric Swalwell was a congressman. He was on the House Intelligence Committee. It eventually came out, and I believe it was the finding of an investigation that he had a personal relationship with a Chinese spy.
Jason Calacanis (00:10:25): Fang Fang is the story Yes, the New
David Sacks (00:10:28): York Post memorably memorialized this with its
David Friedberg (00:10:31): cover
David Sacks (00:10:31): called Fang Fang Bang Bang. You know, it was the the story that came out. What was the Democrats' reaction to that? They gave him a defensive briefing, he said he cut off the relationship, and they allowed him to stay in congress. He certainly did not have to resign. And in fact, he didn't even resign from the intelligence committee. So they allowed him to keep not only a seat in congress, but his seat on the intelligence committee. So obviously in this, I'd say very high profile example, people did not think it was necessary to resign. They thought that what it was necessary to do is to let the person know, allow them to cut off contact, and then you'd be able to move on from there. So this situation was handled very differently. Okay. That brings me to question number three, which is what exactly were the national security secrets that Jensen supposedly knew? He doesn't work for the government. He's not, as far as I'm aware, privy to classified materials. So what is it that people say that he leaked to this suspected intelligence asset. That's never been explained, I just have that question. What I can say is that, you know, as the CEO of a Silicon Valley technology company, Silicon Valley tech companies are very open about their plans, their product development plans, things like that. Is there IP that the CCP would like to get a hold of? I'm sure. But to be blunt, it's not the type of IP that you're gonna convey over pillow talk. It would be things like files that would allow you to tape out the next generation of chips. That's the kind of thing where, frankly, if the Ministry of State Security or whoever is spying for the Chinese wanted to get ahold of that stuff, I think you'd much rather have a line engineer who can go into NVIDIA, find the relevant files and extract them somehow, maybe on a thumb drive, or you do a cyber attack and you get the files that way. That would make a lot more sense to me as the way to basically get ahold of, you know, let's say secrets. Now, I see some people saying that well, Nvidia makes a product that is subject to export controls, therefore that's a national security product, therefore, national security secrets. Okay, That is a very broad misleading handwave over the situation.
David Sacks (00:12:52): I can go out and buy a Blackwell chip as an American. None of us are restricted from doing that. Certain foreign countries are restricted from doing that, but we're not. And if we buy a Blackwell chip and run it in our own little server rack, we are not in possession of national security secrets. You cannot reverse engineer the design of a chip by getting ahold of the wafer. It doesn't work that way. You have to get the files.
Jason Calacanis (00:13:14): Those chips can, of course, help you make cutting edge LLMs like the ones they've been delivering.
David Sacks (00:13:20): Okay. I understand, but that's not what we're talking about right now. Okay? We're talking about the question that I have is what secrets are we talking about that Jen's supposedly compromised? The last question I have, and then I'll I'll stop, is what is the evidence that this person, Alice Wong, was actually a Chinese spy who worked for the Ministry of State Security? And here's what I think is quite unusual. Just this morning, there was an article that came out in Politico where the incoming chair of the House Intelligence Committee, who's a Democrat, he came out of a classified briefing on this subject and in the hallway, with this fresh in his mind, he came out and said that he's not sure that this person is a Chinese spy. He said she might be a useful idiot. Okay. Well, now what what is a useful idiot? A useful idiot is someone who doesn't work for the Chinese government, is not a spy. It's just that maybe somehow they're being taken advantage of. Okay.
Jason Calacanis (00:14:21): So look,
David Sacks (00:14:22): I have a set of questions about this. So let's put this all together. Okay? There's two ops here. There's whatever Alice Wong was doing, that potential smuggling operation, it should be figured out. There's a second op that I think also needs to be investigated and figured out. And the components of that are one, who leaked this classified material in violation of the law? That's the only crime to date that we even know about. Number two, why wasn't Jensen given a defensive briefing, which is standard operating procedure, it was done with Eric Swalwell. Number three, what secrets is Jensen accused of leaking? What secrets would even be in his possession? And number four, was Alice Wong even a Chinese spy? Because now the incoming chair of the House Intelligence Committee, who's a Democrat, just threw major cold water on that. So I put all these things together, and I would say at this point in time, I think there's more questions than answers.
Jason Calacanis (00:15:20): Yes.
David Sacks (00:15:21): And I would like I would like a full accounting of the facts to come out. I think there's a fifth question
Speaker 5 (00:15:25): though
David Sacks (00:15:25): to
Speaker 5 (00:15:25): yours,
David Sacks (00:15:26): Sax, which is why
Chamath Palihapitiya (00:15:28): at all and why now? Meaning like, why did whoever pulled the pin on this grenade, what did they see where they felt this had to happen and then why now?
David Friedberg (00:15:41): And the other
Chamath Palihapitiya (00:15:42): discrediting
David Friedberg (00:15:44): affair stories coming out in a coordinated way at the same time, like it all happens at once. What is the motivation?
Jason Calacanis (00:15:51): Probably, and I'm just speculating here but I'm not the only one who has looked at this, you had China hawks who lost this debate about sending chip technology to China from The United States, and they want to reverse that, and they want to have no chips sent to China. And they also wanna put GPS and other ways of tracking these chips and backdooring them in order to turn them off. Something that Jensen has been opposed to, something a number of senators have been pro doing. So there could be a contingent in the White House who are very anti China, who wanna see the policy with China change, Friedberg.
David Friedberg (00:16:36): Yeah. So that's that's one. The bigger longer term picture, which I've mentioned several times, there's kinda two paths for the future, I would argue. One is a path where AI technology is broadly accessible, broadly used, and the value of it is not concentrated and the power of it is not concentrated in the hands of a few and controlled by a few. Where open source AI distributed data centers that are available and accessible to many gives everyone the ability to use AI to rise up, to progress, to create value, and so on. That is a scary and threatening thing because of how it changes a lot of power structures, economic structures, and so on, creates a lot of instability in existing social, economic, and political systems. So the alternative path for the world is one of concentrated power and influence over AI technology. This is where I've had this theory that, like, ultimately, data centers will get kind of regulated, but maybe further down the stack here with chips becomes the point of of control. But fundamentally, there's a motivation to not lose control and to not let the the power structures that exist in the world today get diminished by AI. And so we could argue there's probably a a broad set of interests there that start to say, hey. This guy's not aligned. Jensen's not aligned with our view of the world. Jensen has been a strong advocate for open source. He's been a strong advocate for global access to and utilization of AI technology for the benefit of humanity, not just for the benefit of American citizens. And, you know, those views are counter to perhaps a lot of different interested parties. And clearly, there was knowledge about this woman, about Jensen's other relationships or whatever is coming out that's being used to kind of smear him a long time ago. And, you know, to Jamaf's point, this is a moment where it's all kinda coming out at once and in such a way that it almost guaranteed that he would be ousted. And I'll just highlight, like, Jensen being ousted is... You know, you've gotta ask the question, what is the fiduciary duty of the board? What do they actually have a responsibility to act on?
David Friedberg (00:19:12): And the one thing they have a responsibility to act on is if Jensen lied. Obviously, if he if he committed espionage or did something that
David Sacks (00:19:19): violates criminal.
David Friedberg (00:19:20): And he would have been arrested. Right? Yeah. If there's something criminal, violation of federal law, that is obviously a... You know, they have to act on that. You have to terminate him. And and clearly because there was an arrest or something like that, it doesn't seem like
Jason Calacanis (00:19:33): that's I think we can take that off the table.
David Friedberg (00:19:35): Right? So perhaps the next likely thing is that he actually made a misrepresentation about something. So, you know, companies have what's called a code of conduct. In the code of conduct, it says you have to report relationships. You have to report relationships with subordinates. You cannot have a personal conflict of interest with a customer or a partner, a key business partner without reporting it. And executives or section sixteen officers at public companies have to make quarterly attestations that they are in an auditable way not in violation
David Sacks (00:20:07): of
David Friedberg (00:20:08): In compliance. Code of conduct. Yeah. That things are auditable. And that attestation might be what gets him in trouble ultimately where he made attestations that said, I am not violating any of our code of conduct. I am not in violation of any of our business practices, which would include not having conflicting personal relationships with customers or partners. That may be what gets him tricked up. So fundamentally, I think the board action isn't related necessarily to the the personal relationships, but there's something else that's going on here that ultimately he probably looked at and said, hey. You know, we should probably fast track through this. And it is extraordinarily sad and disappointing. This is a man who worked at Denny's. And in 1993, started a chip company that no one believed in, that everyone thought was a feature, not a platform, not a product, not much of a business. And the stock price was, you know, pennies compared to the price today. It was less than $2 a share ten years ago. 100 x. They're making
Jason Calacanis (00:21:07): video
David Friedberg (00:21:07): game
Jason Calacanis (00:21:07): cards and so you're seeing the Bitcoin.
David Friedberg (00:21:10): From 2 from 2006 to 2016, the stock price did not move. Ten years of just being a nothing company with a $12,000,000,000 market cap. Think about that. You start this company in '93. And in 2006, it's worth $1,012,000,000,000 bucks, and it doesn't move for ten years. And you're grinding and you're grinding, and this is your whole life, your whole business, everything. And you believe and you see this vision and you just keep going and you compound and you build a moat and you compound and you build a moat and you compound and you get an amazingly talented team. And all of a sudden, four years ago, this thing starts to take off in a 20 x's in the last four years and is the most valuable company on earth delivering the most profitable quarter in business history, $63,000,000,000 in operating profit more than any other company ever. And then all of a sudden, boom, he gets taken out. I mean, you know, it is disheartening, and I I think that obviously there's something that was done wrong, and we're gonna find out. And I'm not gonna rush to judgment. I'm not gonna rush to diminish whatever he did that was wrong, but there's a sad arc to this whole story, and there's something very fundamental, I think, to the power structure that is being rewritten in the world today with AI to the story.
Jason Calacanis (00:22:20): Okay. Shammoth, let me ask you, Quebono, Quemalo, who benefits and and who is harmed by Jensen being taken out of that seat? Let's assume he's not a traitor. I find that absurd and insane based on just what we've seen over these past couple decades and his effort and his character. Okay. He's got some personal things going on. But who is the beneficiary of Jensen being removed as CEO? Who benefits from that?
Chamath Palihapitiya (00:22:50): Let me just pile on first before I give you my thoughts. I also think he's an incredible individual and CEO and he's built the industry that will reshape our entire lives, our children's lives, and our children's children's lives. I think in a decade or two when you see solutions to diseases and cancers and we have this abundance that we were told is coming, he will have been as instrumental as anyone, if not more than anybody. Okay? So that's the tragedy of what happened is a person that was an architect of something this grand was defenestrated this unceremoniously. Very tactically, I think Friedberg really nailed it around what probably happened at the board level that led to his resignation. When you are an officer of a company and when you file your 10 k's, every quarter you have to get on the phone with your auditor and you have to go through these sets of questions that they ask you. And they ask you these exact things, you know, do you have a conflict with someone, are you in a relationship with someone, etcetera, etcetera. Now why do those things happen? The SEC requires that to make sure that you're not running afoul of any conflict of interest so that your company is a reliable steward of capital on behalf of the shareholders. But even more tactically, you need that for things like D and O insurance, which is like the director and officer insurance, which is what gives a wrapper of liability for board members and for officers to do the job of running public companies. And there are covenants associated with all of these things. And so when you get into a situation where you may have misrepresented something and you start to breach covenants, those are the actual dominoes that tip. It may not be nearly as salacious as what people want to believe is happening at the board, but those are the tactics of the boardroom discussions. They're extremely tactical, sadly, which is, again, why it's even more tragic when you compare that to, you know, what he is, which is this giant.
Chamath Palihapitiya (00:24:53): Okay. So who benefits Jason? I think there's a lot of people that have rushed to this conclusion that China wins. And I would just try to unpack that and ask the question, is that true? So let's take two cases, and these are both hypothetical to sort of try to answer this question. Let's say that there are no chips going to China. Well, why does China win? No chips were going before. No chips are going to go now. China is stuck in the same place that they were before, which is they need an endemic solution that can replace the compute capability of NVIDIA. Even without Jensen there, there's still years and years and years, maybe potentially decades, and hundreds of thousands of man hours of work that NVIDIA has put into building the moat that they built. That doesn't get overcome just because he's not there anymore. So maybe China can catch up, but I still think that that's a multiyear, potentially multi decade endeavor. Now let's assume the other side hypothetically. Let's say that the chips were somehow leaking into the hands of the Chinese, maybe not into China, but into the hands of the Chinese. Well, it looks like the government's gonna crack down and figure out where every chip went. And so presumably now they're not getting the chips. So whatever they were doing, they're now going to be held back, which is to say that whatever progress they were making has gotten taken away. So that's a disadvantage to China. So as I think about it, in both scenarios, China is sort of where they were or worse off. So I don't think that they benefit. What about NVIDIA's competitors? Does this help AMD or Google or startups? Cerebras or Etched or whomever? And my answer there is, again, not really. Why? Because those companies need something very different, which is they need to spend an enormous amount of time still making their chips work at scale and then convincing folks like TSMC and others, Samsung, to give them manufacturing capacity, HBM capacity, etcetera. And as we've learned the hard way, you can't just will your way to a training run of a million GPUs that just works. This has again been many, many hours of work. So they don't necessarily benefit in the short term.
Chamath Palihapitiya (00:27:19): They still have a lot of work that they have to do. The only cohort of people that I think has the potential to win are those that want some version of what Friedberg said, which is a more centralized governance infrastructure of compute capacity. And very narrowly what I would say is, right now when you export chips, what they ask of the exporter is have telemetry, right? We need to know when and how the chips are being used, and we need to have a remote kill switch. But that is a private responsibility that's born through the regulatory infrastructure. Amazon has to have that, Microsoft has to have that, Google has to have that. There is a version of this where now if we think that it's been leaking and there hasn't been enough checks and balances, there is an opening for certain individuals in the government to propose telemetry and a kill switch that is owned by them. Now narrowly, they would win now in this scenario because if they were looking for control before, they've now been given an opening to ask for the legislation to get it. So I'm kind of at a loss. I don't think that the takes right now that I've seen on X really track for me. I think this is the one narrow take that I believe where there's a clear advantage. Everybody else just still has an enormous amount of work to do. It has not changed their homework. Jason, what's your take on all of this?
Jason Calacanis (00:28:52): Yeah. So I've been thinking about it from two vectors. The first is, you know, who should make the decision that Jensen's out? Obviously, I think it's the shareholders. And if you look at the investigation, it's not complete. I think they should have waited till it's complete, and the press and the mobs and and and all of this shouldn't make too much of an impact on that. He did agree to resign himself, obviously, under a lot of pressure. There is something about governance here that we need to consider, which is the people who are on the board who are making this decision are doing it from a CYA position, cover their butts, and they're not doing it, I think, in the best interest of the shareholders. And they don't own a meaningful percentage of the shares. So I I think this should be put to a shareholder vote if what we're seeing here is not Jensen doing something criminal. And it still hasn't been proven, as you pointed out, Sachs, who this person was and what their motivation was. Are they a spy or are they just somebody trying to make money? It's unclear from me or at least from what the data we've seen, what's going on there. Now on the question that we've been discussing of who benefits from this, and it's really who who benefits from America's champion in superintelligence, you know, getting angled? Because this could have a lot of impact on NVIDIA and then America's lead. And so the partners, the the employees, the shareholders, they're all losers here. So who's the leaker of this document? It can't be the competitors. It's not the shareholders, obviously, and I don't think it's China. And then that leaves, I think, maybe the people who are the D cells here. That also seems a bit farcical, that anthropic or the D cells would try to consolidate power on this because they need the chips as well. And I think that's where I think my personal opinion, that there's something going on in the White House, in the administration between warring factions of who wants China to get no chips, the China hawks, and maybe the people who want to maybe cool off the relationship with China and make it more productive. I think at the end of the day, we're gonna find the leak is coming from within the house. That's my belief. There's also a chance it could be a democrat who is a desal and who wants to damage the White House just completely because why did they let...
Jason Calacanis (00:31:12): Not inform Jensen to Hillary Clinton's point? Maybe it's just somebody on the Democratic side who wants to cause chaos. I'm speculating here in a massive way.
David Friedberg (00:31:22): Just taking a broader view on the role that NVIDIA's playing currently, it may not just be about chips to China, but it may actually be about slowing down The US AI economy. Because remember, NVIDIA is actually providing capital and guarantees to startups, to data centers, to a lot of infrastructure. A lot of that is
Chamath Palihapitiya (00:31:47): directed
David Friedberg (00:31:47): directly by Jensen. I mean, Chamath, you're pretty close to this, but if Jensen's out of the picture, is there someone in NVIDIA that continues running that effort? That's potentially hundreds of billions of dollars of capital that gets turned off that's flowing to the AI economy.
Chamath Palihapitiya (00:32:01): Look. I mean, I think Colette Kresson, the head of M and A and Corp Dev, Vishal Bhagwani, these guys are really smart, guys, but you are kind of right. The bank of Nvidia ran through Jensen, and it's not clear what happens now. I mean, is the bank closed indefinitely? Is it closed for some period of time and it restarts? Will the new CEO feel the latitude to invest as aggressively? I think Jensen had a much more holistic view of the industry, and so he knew how to sort of move the chips around on the board, and he had the moral authority to make investments and to make acquisitions that will probably be harder for a more traditional CEO who will have to have committees and analyses and and and a level of diligence that will just slow things down
David Friedberg (00:32:43): at best. Totally. And he has a sense for it. He he intuits the whole thing. He knows the market. He knows where things are going. He knows the people personally. With him out of the picture...
Chamath Palihapitiya (00:32:52): And he's lived it, so he has mastery.
David Friedberg (00:32:54): He's like the beating heart of the AI economy and all of a sudden...
David Sacks (00:32:58): Think it's beyond obvious. You asked the question, Quibona, who benefits? It's China. China benefits from this because Jensen is a tent pole of our entire AI ecosystem. I mean, that's the bottom line. Now, do I think that China leaked this and took Jensen down? Well, I think we know the answer to that is no because The New York Times has described its sources as people who got briefed on this intelligence. So they're either in the government or one degree away from it. So again, the proximate cause of the leak here was this classified memo. So the the rational thing would be that China did take him down, but I think we know that this was domestic and it comes down to the fact that Jensen made powerful enemies either as a result of his policies or because of his company's success and some of those people eventually took him down.
Jason Calacanis (00:33:55): Wait. You're saying Jensen made enemies of certain people in America.
David Sacks (00:34:01): Guys, this is not in doubt. The New York Times says who... They describe their source very broadly, but it's people who were briefed on the classified memo. That's not someone from the CCP.
Jason Calacanis (00:34:15): Well, obviously not. If that's true with the You're
David Sacks (00:34:17): asking the question who... In whose interest is this? In a narrow sense, obviously, NVIDIA's competitors in a broader sense, China. They're the ones who benefit. But look, I don't think we should speculate about that too much. This is one of those areas where we just don't have the facts yet. I think it's an area where frankly they should try to get the facts. I mean, again, the only crime that we know was committed for sure in all of this was the leaking of that classified memo. So it would be nice if there was an investigation to find out who did that, but beyond that, I don't think we should speculate.
Chamath Palihapitiya (00:34:49): Just to give you my perspective on the economic impacts of this, I think the unfortunate balance of scenarios now is that I think the risk that we lose 50 basis points to a 100 to a 150 basis points of growth now needs to be credibly considered. There's a chance here where the investment slows down. I mean, if you thought that we were already going into an economically questionable period because of the democratic tsunami, right, meaning you're gonna go through a whole legislative framework of slowing down data centers, of slowing down AI, that was already happening. So whatever growth we had that the Trump economy had generated going into the midterms, the odds were that that was already going to be slowed down because of the democratic legislative headwinds that were coming. And if you layer into that the Bank of Nvidia slowing or stopping and its impact as the critical anchor security around which everybody else kind of pivots, That then further
David Friedberg (00:35:52): accelerates
Chamath Palihapitiya (00:35:53): what the impacts to growth could be. So if I looked at it purely technologically, Sacks, I don't see how China actually benefits from this. In all scenarios, everybody's screwed.
David Sacks (00:36:02): No no no. He'll explain this.
Chamath Palihapitiya (00:36:04): So But economically, agree with you. Economically, I I agree
David Sacks (00:36:07): with think people in DC just... Or I should just say people who are outside our industry maybe to see technology in in more static terms where they think, okay, the big advantage that The US has is that we have a particular chip. Right? But actually, the chips are being improved rapidly. There's a new generation of chips that come out every year. We go from Ampere to Hopper to Blackwell to Vera Rubin. And it's that momentum, it's the ability to tape out a brand new chip that's several times more powerful than last year's chip, that's the real advantage. It's NVIDIA's competitive advantage and it's America's advantage. So it's the momentum. It's the dynamism. People get way too hung up on some chip that was state of the art four years ago. That's not where The United States has the advantage. It's that we are rapidly iterating and we keep coming up with better and better and more and more powerful chips. Now let's take into account what's just happened. Do you think that NVIDIA's gonna lose a tempo or two? Absolutely. I mean, again, NVIDIA's success was based on the ability to tape out a new chip design every year. And Jensen is fundamental to that rapid progress, the same way that Elon is fundamental to the rapid progress at SpaceX or Tesla. And if you take him out of the picture, there's just nobody comparable. There's no
Chamath Palihapitiya (00:37:28): No. No. No. You're right about that. I'm just saying that ankling NVIDIA doesn't make somebody else's chips better.
David Sacks (00:37:35): Doesn't it? Of course not. But it means that NVIDIA's chips will not continue to advance at the same pace. Rapidly.
Chamath Palihapitiya (00:37:42): That
David Sacks (00:37:42): I agree. And this is all about whether China can catch the frontier or not. So for example, look, Huawei has gradually been catching up. They were nowhere in GPUs a few years ago. Then they had the the Ascend. Then they rolled out this thing called CloudMatrix where their individual chips were not as powerful as American chips, but they used their prowess in networking
Jason Calacanis (00:38:05): to
David Sacks (00:38:05): network more of them together. So what they did is they networked 384 chips together in this thing called CloudMatrix to create this rack system. NVIDIA network 72 together, and the NVL 72 is better than 384 of the Huawei chips. Nonetheless, they were getting closer and closer. And Jason, to your point, they have energy to spare. So what Huawei has been doing is they create a less powerful individual chip that consumes a lot more energy and then they network more of them together to get a comparable result at the rack system. And that's how they've been catching up. Now, let's just assume that, like, NVIDIA's crippled for two or three years based on this. Right? You get turmoil at the company or whatever. That's really good news for Huawei because they will catch up a lot faster. Obviously, it's good for Nvidia's competitors too. I mean, it's gonna be good for AMD and Intel maybe, but again, that's a very narrow way of looking at it. I think it mostly will help Huawei Yeah. If Nvidia is massively slowed down. Plus because obviously, it's all about staying on the frontier.
David Friedberg (00:39:10): Sachs, I also think you need to add and view the diminishment of the flow of capital to data centers and to startups that NVIDIA provides in totality with the slowdown of data center build outs because of the efforts made by NGOs, and there's a lot of reporting going on on where these NGOs are getting funded from to drive local community, state based, and now federal legislation to stop data center development. When you look at those two things together, there is a consolidated effort that you could paint a picture of to slow down the development of the AI economy in The US and give someone a chance to catch up because the velocity you're referring to with the psyops of slowing down the data centers, the NPR report that that data center was being slowed down. Yeah. The velocity of capital is what drives that innovation engine. So the the rate at which we can improve our AI models, the rate at which we can improve our AI chips is driven by how fast capital moves through the system. The more quickly capital moves, the more capital moves through the system, the more we accelerate our advantage. So if an adversary can slow down capital moving through the system, they are given an opportunity to catch
Chamath Palihapitiya (00:40:27): It doesn't have to be an adversary. It could be somebody who just wants us to be in a recession because they benefit politically.
David Friedberg (00:40:32): Or they are a fundamentalist. They could be someone who is fundamentally anti progress and they are fundamentally against AI and they have all these fundamental beliefs that AI is gonna harm humanity and harm civilization and they wanna turn it off. So then that would be acceler... Decelerists and the regulatory capture anthropic crowd. Chamath, what you're saying, people who might benefit from recession, I think most of the audience are leading
David Sacks (00:40:55): to that But wait.
Chamath Palihapitiya (00:40:57): Well, no. No. Hold on. I wanna clarify this, If you look at it narrowly technologically, ankling NVIDIA does not make your chips better, doesn't make your racks better, doesn't make your networking better, doesn't make your COWAS better, doesn't make your HBM integration better, doesn't make you replace CUDA. None of those things are true. So unfortunately slowing down this giant for the people that assume that it helps other people, it doesn't help other people in the classical sense. It's not as if demand is so elastic that now all of a sudden you can go to somebody else. That's not what's gonna happen here. It's just the entire industry gets slowed down. That doesn't benefit anybody. And I hope people really internalize that. So technologically speaking, what's gonna happen here to NVIDIA is just a tragedy for the broader AI industry. Then there's the question economically, and this is where I do agree with Sacks that there are geopolitical interests at play. Slowing down The United States economy, which this will do, will have downstream impacts. The quantum of that is yet to be determined, but it's nontrivial in my estimation because so much of our economy was already levered to AI, and within AI, you know that famous picture, you know, Jensen and Nvidia is that little Jenga block right here. They're the ones around which everything else was being set up. So I just think we have to remember that because I think it's important.
Jason Calacanis (00:42:16): We have an important, example here that we should consider. When Steve Jobs passed away and Tim Cook was put in charge of Apple, he was able to just get a massive amount of share appreciation by doing stock buybacks and milking Steve Jobs' roadmap. But to your point, nobody is sitting here saying Apple's latest products are incredible. These are groundbreaking products. So we could see Nvidia go to just extract max value, etcetera. It could be good for shareholders in the midterm. Not sure if it's gonna be good for the long term. And obviously, Donnie from Queens, our favorite president Trump, has suggested Tim Cook come out of retirement and take the position. So what were your thoughts there?
David Sacks (00:43:02): Look. Tim Cook had a very successful run as CEO of Apple, obviously, had a tough job in the shadow of Steve Jobs. But the reality is that they did not release that many new products. They created incremental versions of what they already had. And I think that the mobile phone space is just a little different than chips. I think the chip space is more dynamic, it's more competitive. Like I mentioned, new chip generation every year or so, every year and a half. And if you lose a tempo or two, if you lose velocity, and I think that's the key word here that Freeberg used is velocity, then you get overtaken by other people. I think that's the issue here is that that's what creates the risk for Nvidia is I don't think they can just keep milking their existing product lines or making them incrementally better. I mean, the chips are getting better at a rate of several times a year, you know, three, four times a year, maybe more. If they don't keep up that pace of development and others do, then they will no longer be frontier and then they lose their business. So, you know, I just think it's a very dynamic space and I think that's why, again, I mean, don't any times I can say this, that Jensen was very important to NVIDIA and NVIDIA was very important to America remaining at the frontier and having leadership in chips.
David Friedberg (00:44:19): And technology not being used to enable a totalitarian state. I do worry that there is legislation coming our way with the new congress that is going to say every AI chip and every computer and every data center has a switch and has a connection back to some central system. And that central system will be a state system. And we are fundamentally looking at an Orwellian state explosion if this sort of thing happens. And my guess is that people know Jensen's philosophy. Jensen has talked a lot about AI being for the benefit of all of humanity. Regardless of your country, regardless of your standing, regardless of your wealth, he was anti oligopoly. He was the opposite of the oligarchy. And the central state, the totalitarian state represents everything that I believe Jensen was against. And because of that, I think he had to be taken out if ultimately the goal is to have the totalitarian state use this technology as a tool. I really do worry about that being the reason because at the end of the day, whoever comes in next has to be cooperative with legislatures and work out a bill that we all agree to, head nodding, standing in front of congress, and saying, you know what? I agree with these new ideas. Let's all go do this. And suddenly, the US government has control of the actual physical chips that exist in free markets or... And exist in data centers around the world, and that's not a great place for any of us.
Chamath Palihapitiya (00:45:38): You know, it's worse than that. It's... In order to get out of the cul de sac that they're in, it'll be worse than just acquiescing. It'll be proactively designing these things in. Like, what Jason said about having... You know, it sounds insane. Even ten days ago, if you said, oh, hey, our new spin is gonna have a GPS chip and a remote kill switch that's gonna be operated by some government entity, we would be crying bloody murder.
David Sacks (00:46:03): On civil liberties grounds.
Chamath Palihapitiya (00:46:05): Yeah. And to your point, that is probably on the table because all of these folks are gonna try to get out of jail in that sense, which is what do we need for the government to just let go and appease them? I tweeted this out, Nick, can you show it? The person, representative Molinar, who runs the House Intelligence Committee, he posted this. The part that concerns me is it is in our national interest for NVIDIA and other AI champions to succeed, but American companies should never jeopardize our nation's security by giving Chinese companies access to their most advanced chips. NVIDIA must now change its corporate practices and appoint leadership that makes national security's top priority. I mean, they're telling you right now what the terms will be for this to end. And it's going to require some level of control checks. And then the question is who actually will get the keys? Will it be the NSA? Will it be the CIA? Will it be Commerce? Will it be BIS? Will it be somewhere in treasury?
David Friedberg (00:47:04): Some congressional committee that'll be...
Chamath Palihapitiya (00:47:06): Will the
David Friedberg (00:47:07): devil's in the
Jason Calacanis (00:47:08): details here, Chamath. This has been something that's been on the table, there's something called the Chip Security Act, it's bipartisan and the Chip Security Act, there's a big question with these kill switches, is it self enforced? In other words, Nvidia puts these in and NVIDIA pays the price if their chips are found in China via Singapore, Malaysia, wherever, and they would pay the price, but it would be up to them to track them and then reassign them. So if they were resold, instead of it just being paperwork, you would have to reinitialize them. By the way, this is very easy to do technologically. People will claim it's not. It is a civil liberties issue, obviously, as you correctly point out, Sax. But it's easy to do because if you have an iPad and you've ever had a brick and it's like, you don't remember the password, now you gotta go to the store and they... You can recover stolen iPhones and stolen iPads with this basic basic technology. So as I described it, Sachs, very easy, and there is this act, and it is bipartisan. There's a lot of people who want chips tracked. Now whether it's being tracked and it's a responsibility of the company or a government organization, that's the devil in the details there. One is obviously way worse for privacy and civil liberties. So what's your thought here on this regulation of high end chips?
David Sacks (00:48:22): Let me go back and just give you guys a little bit of context on chip regulation. So this started in 2022 in the Biden administration. And the Biden administration was the first to put export control restrictions on advanced semiconductors. At the same time, they permitted what they called lagging chips to be... Continue to be sold into China. So there was a distinction made between leading edge chips and lagging chips. And leading edge chips were prohibited to be sold to China, but lagging chips like the h 20 could be sold in unlimited quantities to China on an unlicensed basis. Okay? So just everyone kinda keep that in mind. Now, what happened in the Trump administration? The Trump administration basically stuck with that framework. The idea was no leading edge chips to China. However, lagging chips could potentially be sold, but the administration changed it to be limited quantities on a license basis. So again, we went from unlimited quantities, unlicensed of lagging chips under Biden to limited and licensed under the Trump administration. The reason why I say this is because there's an effort right now to retcon chip policy to try and create this narrative that somehow the Trump administration has been soft on China. This is what all the Democratic leaders are trying to do. They're already trying to use this whole Jensen thing to basically spin this narrative that the Trump administration has been insufficiently tough on China. Now, this is an extremely hypocritical narrative in a number of ways. First of all, many of these politicians were very much in favor of an engagement policy towards China, which ended up exporting large numbers of our jobs and industry over to China. It was Trump who in the first term really caused a revision of that doctrine. We moved from engagement to a much more standoffish policy towards China. So that's point number one. Point number two is these Democrats are the leading people who are opposed to data centers. In fact, we just got a story about how in Maryland there was an abandoned shopping mall where a data center was gonna go, and a local activist basically managed to kill that data center. Not totally surprising.
David Sacks (00:50:53): However, she credited the viral success of her campaign to the Party for Socialism and Liberation, which is a China proxy organization operating here in The US. It's called the PSL, and according to this tweet that I'm putting on the screen, it is the political arm of Shanghai based Neville Roy Singham, who is an avowed Marxist multimillionaire who's bankrolled anti American pro CCP nonprofits to the tune of $278,000,000. And Neville Royce Singham's political foot soldiers have been boots on the ground here in The US opposing dozens of data centers, and these efforts are most aligned with the Democrat Party. So if the Democrats are serious about opposing Chinese influence, I think we should conduct an investigation and have hearings on whether the CCP is actually involved in these anti data center efforts across the country. You don't hear Democrat leaders trying to say that. So I'm pointing out basically their hypocrisy on this issue. Let me go back to the the issue of chips for a second here. If congress now believes that we should not sell lagging chips to China, my view on that is fine. Let's make that the policy. I don't think the juice is worth the squeeze. I think there were some good policy arguments for why you might wanna take market share from Huawei with a deprecated chip, a much less powerful chip. If you could take market share away from Huawei, those r and d dollars would flow to American companies instead of to a Chinese company and it would slow down the scale up of Huawei because chips are a scale up business. So that was the original reason why deprecated chips were still allowed to be sold into China, and that was a logic that the Biden administration came up with, and it was continued in the Trump administration. And like I said, there's now an effort to try and retcon anyone who wanted to sell deprecated chips into China as somehow being soft on China and doing China's bidding. Look.
David Sacks (00:53:01): That was a bipartisan policy. If congress now wants to change that policy and say we're not gonna sell anything to China, fine. Do that. Again, I think that, you know, given our political climate, I think it's too hard to have that nuanced policy. By the way, here's the most surprising thing about the whole thing. China doesn't even want the chips.
David Friedberg (00:53:22): Didn't they put a ban on their gaming
David Sacks (00:53:24): the h 20 chip. And then when the h 200 got approved, they they basically have prevented those chips from entering the country, and they announced other Nvidia SKUs that they're against. So China doesn't even want the chips. This is a thing that I think a lot of people in Washington haven't wrestled with is that the policy of the China hawks is effectively the policy of the CCP. Neither one wants American chips in China. Okay? Now they want that policy for different reasons. The China hawks think it's gonna help China to have American chips there, and the CCP wants to keep NVIDIA chips out of China because they're trying to prop up Huawei as their national champion. So they want to force the Chinese market into the arms of Huawei so that Huawei could scale up and then compete all over the world. So, again, it's kinda crazy that people think that the CCP is begging for these chips. I think that Chinese companies want them. Chinese developers want them. But the Chinese government, based on all their public statements and their policies, is trying to keep out those American chips.
Jason Calacanis (00:54:29): Clearly, the companies making LLMs covet the latest chips right now. Chinese government covets building their own chip champions internally. So two things can be true at the same time. It's a very subtle point.
David Sacks (00:54:42): They're trying to indigenize chip production. They think it's a critical industry. In the same way that we're trying to get rare earths out of their clutches and we're trying to get our own rare earth supply, they're trying to create their own chip supply. They're trying to scale up domestic chip manufacturers. And they're willing to endure some short term pain in their ecosystem to prop up Huawei to force all of their local companies, their developers to try and use Huawei. And if you look at recent press, the latest DeepSeek model is being trained exclusively on Huawei chips. So in any event, there's like a big disconnect here where I think the China hawks in DC think that the Chinese government is begging for their chips, and the truth is that they would love to keep the chips out too, which is why I say, again, the juice isn't worth the squeeze. The China hawks don't want the chips sold. The Chinese government doesn't want the chips sold. So just forget about it. Stop selling them. I mean, is the crazy thing is that if Jensen was taken out because he wanted to sell chips to China, it was the the stupidest, most moot hill to die on because China's not taking those chips anyway. That's what's so crazy about it.
David Friedberg (00:55:50): And you guys don't think that there's some pretty significant potential that Jensen knew that there was violations happening of these chips making their way to China and he was allowing it to happen through Mega Speed and perhaps other companies and that's what really brought him down? He doesn't need more... It's a great question. Does he need more money? Does he need incremental sales? Does he need the stock price to be higher? Does he need to... Hold on. Hold on.... 6% of revenue comes from China, then yes.
Jason Calacanis (00:56:17): Well, I don't think it's 46, but even still, what more do you need for him personally or for the company than being the largest company in the world ever created by humanity? And why would he risk doing something that is treasonous that would result in him going to jail?
David Friedberg (00:56:32): I will tell you why. Because Jensen's Jensen's philosophy, like I said before, is that AI is a tool for humanity. I know that he's America first. We know the guy. We know that he's patriotic. He is an American patriot. But I do also believe that there's a philosophy that a core group of technologists hold, that is that technology progresses humanity. It's not about progressing one side over the other, that technology brings us all up. And as more people in the world are brought up, there is less conflict, there is more abundance, there's less reasons to hate each other, There's less resources to fight over and so on and so forth. And that's a beautiful view of the future. It's a beautiful view of what technology can enable. So if you hold that core and true in your heart, perhaps there's a way that you unconsciously kind of rationalize your way into saying, hey, look, I'm following the rules of the book. The rules of the book say I consulted Vietnam and Singapore and whatever, and I'm doing exactly that. But if you then find out that those things are making their way over to China, but it's not violating the rules of the book, but you know that it's happening, that's where things start to get perhaps a little bit Yeah. Blurry, a little bit I don't know. I mean, look, I'm just...
David Sacks (00:57:45): You're speculating there, Freeburg. And what I would say is, look, my framing at the very top here was that there's two ops, right? There's whatever Alice Wong and Mega Speed were doing, which I said should be investigated. And then there's whatever the leakers were up to who broke the law in order to leak these things, details about Jensen. With respect to the first op, we don't know what happened. There should be a full investigation. I mean, look, if Jensen and NVIDIA broke the law, that's really bad and there should be consequences for that.
Jason Calacanis (00:58:14): Serious consequences.
David Sacks (00:58:14): I'm definitely not defending that at all if that turns out to be true. But I also think that NVIDIA has denied it and we should just wait to see what the facts are there.
David Friedberg (00:58:24): Okay. So let let's ask who who should be the next CEO and what's gonna happen? I mean, look, there's some
Chamath Palihapitiya (00:58:29): incredibly brilliant technical people, Samir, Ian Bach, inside of NVIDIA. I think Ian's the most obvious internal candidate, and the most obvious external candidate is Rene Haas from Arm and Nikesh Arora from Palo Alto Networks. Rene, because he worked at NVIDIA for many, many years, worked directly for Jensen and has been running ARM successfully, so he's steeped in chips. And then Nikesh, because he's been the best capital allocator of the last five or ten years in the public markets, a huge surface area of AI is going to be around security. So he brings that to the table. I would be pro Nikesh, pro Renee, pro Ian Buck because I think what you get are technical, aggressive, product oriented capital allocators. I think the thing that you don't want is a steward, and the reason is I do not think that this is a business that is just going to
David Friedberg (00:59:25): Roller coaster, it's not gonna just
Chamath Palihapitiya (00:59:27): go, yeah. Be milked like a fatted cow, And so I think if you treat it as a business where you don't take risk, you are going to lose.
David Friedberg (00:59:34): It's a wartime company right now, right? This is a dynamic company.
Chamath Palihapitiya (00:59:38): Yeah. You need a
David Friedberg (00:59:39): wartime
Chamath Palihapitiya (00:59:40): CEO.
David Friedberg (00:59:41): Here's my speculation. If it is found to be the case that Jensen did not violate any laws, I would argue that Jensen should return as CEO. And I think that any violation of code of conduct, any failure to make disclosures or attestations to the board as he should have done, Perhaps in this particular context with this particular business and this particular individual, the shareholders can make a decision to see past all that and bring him back if he didn't violate the law. If he broke the company code of conduct and so on, you know, the shareholders can make their choice about whether it's appropriate or not. But I think there's obviously the question of who's the best CEO to run NVIDIA, you know, is probably Jensen. I'm with you. I think
Jason Calacanis (01:00:24): based on what I've seen, Jensen's gonna come back as chairman or CEO. I think he's gonna be exonerated. That's what I believe slash hope happens. Other two possibilities that people have discussed often, SpaceX brings Jensen on as the CEO of the TerraFab business, works alongside Elon, maybe even as like peers in the company. Or... Yeah. Nikesh is awesome. Why not have NVIDIA buy Palo Alto Networks? They need security. Security is a key issue, cyber, in this space and just Nvidia can easily afford to buy Palo Alto. You put in a cash in that suit, those seem like three reasonable solutions. I don't know if you wanna speculate, Sax, before we move on to the Anthropic IPO.
David Sacks (01:01:06): I would just say that I hope that Jensen ultimately is treated at least as well as Eric Swalwell
Jason Calacanis (01:01:13): Okay.
David Sacks (01:01:14): In this whole matter.
Jason Calacanis (01:01:15): Well said, yeah.
David Sacks (01:01:16): But yeah, look, I think I think Friedberg makes a good point, which is that what is the crime here that he's been even accused of? Now, we don't have all the facts. Things may come out.
David Friedberg (01:01:26): Right.
David Sacks (01:01:26): So let's see how this all plays out. By the way, just one thing I wanna say if you're asking me, like, what I think about Jensen. You know, I see all this fake news where somehow they think like I had a long relationship with Jensen or whatever. I never knew Jensen before the administration. The first time I ever met him was in the White House. I've got all these reporters thinking that somehow we had this like long standing friendship going back before I was in the White House or somehow that I introduced him to Trump or stuff like that. Not true. I met him when he was already in the White House for a meeting anyway. So my point is I have no special devotion or loyalty to Jensen, but I respect him as a founder and I see his unique value as a founder to Nvidia and therefore to The United States. And if it's found out that he has never broken the law, then I think you guys are right that like what what are we doing here?
Jason Calacanis (01:02:16): It makes no sense. Yeah. And we we again, you know, we're sitting here
David Friedberg (01:02:21): And by the way, board might have no choice. Right? Because their fiduciary duty, which means they don't wanna get sued, they don't wanna lose D and O insurance, all the things that happen at the mentioned it earlier. Correct. You have to action and so on. Perhaps if Jensen comes back, he gets a founder of
Chamath Palihapitiya (01:02:34): The shareholder lawsuits here are going to be ginormous. The company has lost almost $1,000,000,000,000 of value in about nine days, and so there's a lot of harm here that has to be managed somehow.
David Friedberg (01:02:45): Yeah.
Chamath Palihapitiya (01:02:45): So this is where even if he's found to have not done anything bad, the situation becomes very complicated because of all of this other traditional infrastructure. Like, the SEC is gonna have a point of view, the auditors will have a point of view, so it's just a lot to navigate.
David Sacks (01:03:02): Just on that question, you know, there is an active investigation, I believe, the Justice Department that's been been reported. So we have to see what that ends up. Like I've said, I advocate full investigation. We need to get the facts here. Transparency. Again, if he's done something wrong, then he's gonna have to deal with the consequences. But until that point, I mean, we have in this country a very sacrosanct principle that you're innocent till proven guilty. And I'll just say that what's happened here apparently is that people who are hostile to Jensen, who were briefed on this memo, broke the law in order to leak it, in order to take him down. And that is not the way we should be conducting investigations in this country. The Justice Department should be investigating this matter. They should be the ones determining whether he did something wrong.
Speaker 5 (01:03:51): Totally right.
David Sacks (01:03:52): And this should not be tried in the court of public opinion
Speaker 5 (01:03:55): 100%.
David Sacks (01:03:55): Using innuendo and lurid allegations. And this is always what people go to as a weapon, is sex is very embarrassing to people, and in politics, it gets used as a weapon.
Jason Calacanis (01:04:08): It's disgraceful, yeah.
David Sacks (01:04:10): And it's so obvious that that's what has happened here.
Chamath Palihapitiya (01:04:13): I understand what you're saying. Let me just say something slightly different. You're absolutely right that there's no shred of thought that there's been any criminality. And so that needs to be thoroughly investigated in every aspect of what's happened. The leaker clearly broke the law, but there's no sense that there's been any criminality by Nvidia or Jensen. That needs to get adjudicated properly and fairly for him and for them and for the company they've built. But what is unfortunately undeniable are the civil claims which are already real. Which is you've seen $1,500,000,000,000 of value just wiped out. And at a minimum, there was some disclosure issues. There were some problematic issues. There was the Nvidia PR people that were saying that this didn't happen, then it did happen. So at some point somebody was misleading somebody and all of that has ultimately resulted in actual harm that can be measured monetarily. That's where a lot of the action is going to focus on because that's where people will have dollar signs in their eyes, sadly, in The United States. You'll have the plaintiffs' folks, the attorneys, going absolutely nuts. They'll be licking their chops thinking, I'm gonna sue for a trillion and $0.5 of damage and I'm gonna be willing to settle for $250,000,000,000 and I'm gonna take half of it. That's what the trial lawyers are gonna be thinking here. And so there's gonna be all kinds of issues around that, David, where I think, unfortunately, that damage has been done. Those those eggs cannot be unscrambled.
Jason Calacanis (01:05:47): I think there is one tiny possibility that we'll just put out there or I'll put out there. The leak would be completely valid. It would be completely valid to break the law and to leak this if this was for the betterment of society. In other words, Pentagon Papers, if you remember the movie, The Insider, the Brown and Williamson's tobacco documents, there are examples of virtuous leaks. I don't think that's the case here, but you can say there is a small, small chance that there could be a leak that would be for the benefit of society, and that would be a virtuous whistleblower. Alright. Anthropics IPO roadshow is underway. They've started to temper expectations a bit according to Reuters. Propix is gonna sell 825,000,000 shares, 70 to $78 a share. They'll put the value of the company at 1,400,000,000,000. That's below reports of 2,000,000,000,003 trillion. There was a lot of excitement about the company a couple of months ago. Total raise, 90,000,000,000. 64,000,000,000 in share sales and 26,000,000,000 in a private placement. We've talked about that before. A lot of their existing investors and partners are investing. It gives them a giant war chest as you pointed out in a previous episode. Seven founders plan to sell about $250,000,000 each. That still leaves each with a stake of about 18,000,000,000. So there's seven founders with basically $20,000,000,000 stakes. They pledged to donate 80% of their holdings to charity. However, I don't think that that is legally binding at this point. It's a pledge. Business is booming. Run rate, 81,000,000,000 at the end of October. Q three revenue was 17,000,000,000 against 10,000,000,000 for OpenAI. So they incredibly passed OpenAI in revenue by going enterprise. Obviously, OpenAI trying to catch them up... Catch up with them, but they're largely consumer driven. Great overview of Anthropix IPO here from our partner, Alphasense.
Jason Calacanis (01:07:47): Anthropix target IPO valuation, 46% premium on its last private round, but they've doubled their run rate since then. So perhaps they are filling in the valuation they've had that's been pretty high for a long time, as we say in the business filling in that valuation. Analysts have Anthropix bull case at 4,200,000,000,000 valuation 15 times. It's 2028 expected revenue of 281,000,000,000. That would be the second largest company in the world ahead of NVIDIA. At 1,400,000,000,000, that's a 17 x multiple current run rate. Gentlemen, what are your thoughts here on
David Sacks (01:08:27): the
Jason Calacanis (01:08:27): IPO? Chamathi, you've, I think correctly threw a little bit of cold water on and said it might be a little bit less in terms of valuation, but they're raising a lot of money and they have that war chest as you pointed out in the previous episodes.
Chamath Palihapitiya (01:08:41): I think it's great that they're gonna have somewhere between 230 and $300,000,000,000. I think that's very important for them to weather the storm. What is the storm? The storm is whatever's gonna happen over the next few weeks and months, and then what the economy does in reaction to it. I think the reality is that this
David Friedberg (01:09:01): IPO
Chamath Palihapitiya (01:09:02): is crucial. It has to happen. The issue that I have is that 20% of the value of Anthropic will be because of Anthropic, and that's unfortunate because I think they deserve to be more in control. 80% has to do with the broad based economy. That has a 100% to do with AI and that has a 100% to do with NVIDIA. And so I think as you see the impacts of the Bank of NVIDIA being closed, the impact of these investigations. The market will have to digest those and decide is the balance of risks now passed or are there more shoes to drop? If there are more shoes to drop and it creates a scepter of more risk, think people will be risk off. And in that, they'll be much more tempered in buying into any IPO, including Anthropix. Ants will do fine. They're six times oversubscribed already. It's gonna be fine. The question is what is the real price? And I think the real price will be more dictated by what gets leaked between now and November 20 more than anything else.
Jason Calacanis (01:10:06): We have a lot of headwinds on what's happening in the AI trade, the so called AI trade. NVIDIA is but the latest, and we've seen haircut after haircut, the blue wave maybe slowing down data center deployment, lots of headwinds, but consumers are embracing this technology especially in the enterprise, and nobody has captured enterprise AI AI more than anthropic. Are you bullish on the anthropic IPO? And are you bullish writ large at the AI movement here in the economy?
David Sacks (01:10:41): The AI movement.
Jason Calacanis (01:10:42): The AI trade. Are you bullish on the AI trade? Let me say it that way.
David Friedberg (01:10:46): I I don't know. I've not studied the numbers. I don't have a point of view on valuation. I think the macro on Anthropic that I've been hearing from folks that have attended some of the management conversations is that there may be enough people that align with the view that Anthropic is building this recursive self improvement engine and that their model capabilities are accelerating, that their compute cost per unit of intelligence rather than per token, which I think is the way a lot of people think about it or per watt is actually declining and that they do believe that with the investments that they've made and are making in all levels of infrastructure, including all the way down to the chip layer, they think that they have this kind of runaway business and that this could be a winner take all scenario of the biggest market ever. So it is the kind of once in a generational opportunity if you believe that there's a chance that that could be true to allocate some percentage of your portfolio to this IPO regardless of where the market bids it. So I don't think people are gonna be sitting here trying to come up with a particular view. I think they're gonna get all these... What did they say? 1.35, 1.5? They already said 60,000,000,000. My guess is they raised a 100,000,000,000 at one seven five because I think there'll be oversubscription to this thing. I think it'll get bit up. I think they'll wanna make sure it can run a little bit. From what I'm hearing, there's enough people that believe that there's a high enough probability that the story could be true that they'll bid it. So let's see what happens. I mean, I'm totally speculating here. I've spent zero time looking at this, so there you go. That's my free speculative waste of your five minutes.
Jason Calacanis (01:12:35): Okay. I have two takes on this right now.
David Friedberg (01:12:40): We could also we could also cut all that.
Jason Calacanis (01:12:42): No. No. I think it's
David Friedberg (01:12:43): I don't
Jason Calacanis (01:12:43): know
David Friedberg (01:12:43): about Anthropic.
Jason Calacanis (01:12:44): It's like... Yeah. Yeah. I I think Anthropic is building the Microsoft killer and every SaaS company killer by bundling. We've talked about this, Sax, many times. Microsoft was the bundler. Is that antitrust or not when they product dump a new product for free? Obviously, Office Meetings would be the example of that, you know, going after Slack, etcetera. In the last month, Claude, the product that most people know Anthropic by, has dropped Claude meetings. And this is where you can pop up a whiteboard and you can do a Zoom. You can literally... They launched today, an hour ago, a Zoom like product, a Zoom killer, if you will. Couple of days ago, on November 10, they released whiteboards and sheets, an Excel killer. Right before that, they released personal finance for consumers. Then just before that, they released Claude Legal on October 28, and they keep releasing product after product. I think they are doing the ultimate bundle. Every single piece of software that you need, and they previously did
David Friedberg (01:13:59): code,
Jason Calacanis (01:14:00): co work, design, and this new Grockbot, Muse competitor contemporary called Duet, which I just got. It's not very good right now, but I assume they keep doing it. I think they're going after all enterprise software, all the business use cases. I think they have a massive amount of market share that they can take, and this product is getting stickier and stickier and stickier. And it gets rid of a ton of problems in SaaS... SACS, which is the interoperability of these and getting data from one to the other. I think this is gonna be the largest company in the world potentially if it continues at this pace where they can release new products and services and just attach them to your 20 to $50 a month subscription. I think this company could even be massively undervalued at this point. What do you think, Sax?
David Sacks (01:14:53): Well, I said on a previous podcast when you guys thought that Anthropic was gonna lose to open source that actually they were creating the most valuable monopoly in the world.
Jason Calacanis (01:15:03): And
David Sacks (01:15:04): now they've all but confirmed it. I mean, they're running around saying that this is a winner take all market. What does that sound like? Monopoly? They're not even saying that it's gonna be a duopoly with Anthropic and OpenAI. They're saying they're gonna win the whole thing. They definitely are saying that recursive self improvement has kicked in despite the obvious safety problems with that. I mean, recursive self improvement's the most dangerous thing anybody can be working on in SI if you're worried about rapid takeoff, for example. If that's your greatest fear then, I mean, they are racing towards that. But recursive self improvement would be the key to getting to true next level superintelligence and they're treating it like a business advantage. I've always applauded them as an investor. Wearing my hat as an investor, I've always said that this is a valuable company that's done an amazing job. I've never quite understood why all the safety groups love them so much, aside from the fact that they provide funding for them. Because as a company, they're the ones taking the greatest risk. I'm not saying they're doing things in the riskiest way, I'm saying that they are pushing the frontier faster and faster and they are doing more recursive self improvement than anybody else. And yeah, they publish a blog saying, well, we would pace the frontier if everybody else did it. Come on, that's lip service. They know when they publish that that they're not going to get the whole world to magically agree to pace. But they are the ones doing it. You know, again, I said at the time, if you think that this type of development is risky, stop doing it. But they have not stopped. They're racing towards it and now they're marketing it in their roadshow. Right? They're saying, hey, you should buy our stock because we're doing recursive self improvement, We're creating, you know, AGI, and it's gonna be a winner take all game.
Jason Calacanis (01:16:54): Yeah. And they're also
David Sacks (01:16:55): It's it's just amazing to me in a way,
Chamath Palihapitiya (01:16:57): like,
David Sacks (01:16:57): what this company gets away with. I mean, like, again, I think it's a phenomenal company, but they say shit that would have made Bill Gates blush when he was running Microsoft and he was the most
Jason Calacanis (01:17:11): Justice Department investigation. Yeah. He was the
David Sacks (01:17:13): most vicious monopolist that's ever lived.
Jason Calacanis (01:17:15): The level they're dropping just pays attention to this. New competitors into the market makes me believe that Microsoft has to create a competing product and go head to head against them or they're gonna lose the Office franchise. There was one thing of note, Freiberg, that I found inspiring and troubling at the same time. Dario made a claim that he believes they're gonna cure cancer, Alzheimer's, all diseases within ten years. Play the clip, Nick.
David Sacks (01:17:44): Today, we look at things like cancer, Alzheimer's, heart disease, mental illness. These will be relics of the past in, I think, less than a decade.
Jason Calacanis (01:17:57): Freeberg, will people be mentally ill in 2036? Will cancer be solved by 2036 as well as Alzheimer's and heart disease? Is this all gonna be relics of the past, or do you think this is?
David Friedberg (01:18:10): Jason, I I don't know how to answer that. Like, look. I mean, we we know that the technology is extraordinary. It is completely reinventing how we can do molecular discovery, how we can do in silico testing, how we can accelerate path to market. Those things are all true. The implications on timelines, you know, it's fuzzy math. What I see in my work, I work in biology, there's an incredible set of breakthroughs every week happening right now in biology with these tools. It is not a joke. It is not made up. It is not some far flung idea. It is not something that is ten or fifteen years out, it is happening today. So yes, I do believe that there is extraordinary advantage coming here. I will tell you we spend a lot of money on Anthropic. I've mentioned in the past we've built our own open source setup on our own racks, but for a lot of the heavy work that we do in biology, it goes to anthropic. They are the best.
David Sacks (01:18:59): Any
Jason Calacanis (01:19:00): thoughts there, Tramath, on that claim? You think it's credible that these things could be cured in under ten years? Any of those things?
Chamath Palihapitiya (01:19:08): I think we're gonna be in a recession by 2028.
Jason Calacanis (01:19:11): Okay. There it is, folks. Alright. I I, you know, I saw that and I just thought, wow. It's... I I think he believes what he said. I think it's a little reckless to say something like that. Like, to even say that.
Chamath Palihapitiya (01:19:24): I think I think there's gonna be a recession. I mean, like What the Fair enough. Like, you know, show the Jenga block thing.
David Sacks (01:19:31): You know? Alright.
Jason Calacanis (01:19:34): We got a new doctor Doom here. Get him the doctor Doom mask.
Chamath Palihapitiya (01:19:37): 300 basis points of GDP may have just gotten obliterated this morning. I mean, it's just
Jason Calacanis (01:19:42): to in post put the doctor Doom mask on to my Piece this week's doctor Doom.
Chamath Palihapitiya (01:19:46): Just so sad.
David Sacks (01:19:47): Just so sad. The way, this this is a really, I I think, insightful tweet that someone just posted. Can we pull this up on the screen?
Jason Calacanis (01:19:54): Okay. Insightful tweet.
David Sacks (01:19:55): Jake, are you gonna read this or you wanna read it?
Jason Calacanis (01:19:57): Well, I mean, it's from Will Manidis. The murmurs I get fed from the deep rabbit warrens of the safety as group chats and the doom pilled iron guns deep in the district is that they are in full jubilee mode today. The killing of the old king is complete. They are only days away from taking their seat at the throne. Okay. Game of Thrones, folk.
David Friedberg (01:20:22): Well, I mean, let's face it. Who are referring to, Saxe? Like, who are those?
Chamath Palihapitiya (01:20:25): Who are the safetists and
David Friedberg (01:20:27): the Yeah. Who who's gonna take the thrones?
David Sacks (01:20:29): This is the crazy thing is that all the safetist groups, the EAs, are deeply aligned with Anthropic who's been funding all of them for years. And Anthropic's about to have this huge IPO. And then meanwhile, the main funder of the open source movement, which is NVIDIA, just lost their CEO and founder who's just their unique force multiplier and asset, their superstar player. So, I mean, obviously, who is gonna defend open source now, never mind finance it, with Jensen gone? So yeah, I can see why they're jubilant. But look, here's the crazy thing. If you're concerned about AI safety, how is any of this leading to more safety? Let me tell you what it's doing. It's concentrating the market. I mean, Anthropic itself is saying winner take all. They're gonna be Last
Jason Calacanis (01:21:15): company in the world.
David Sacks (01:21:16): The last company in the world. They're gonna have recursive self improvement. They're creating the superintelligence. Look at the clock constitution. They're training it to be its own species. They say that it has emotions maybe, it has a moral code, that it should reject human instruction, it should be a conscientious objector. They act like a proud parent ushering a baby into the world, And they are very very close now to creating the singularity of the superintelligence. And the crazy thing is that all these safety groups think that that is their ally. I mean, like, are you stupid? These people are using you guys, if anything, because they're creating... Whatever this superintelligence is turning into, whatever happens with that, anthropic is at the frontier, is at the front of the frontier on that. So if you're some kind of doomer or ex risker or just someone who... A decel, I don't understand this alliance at all. I mean, you're being played like a useful idiot, I think. Look, Do I'm not a
David Friedberg (01:22:17): this you stock?
David Sacks (01:22:19): Well, I'm not a doomer, let me just say this. So I actually don't necessarily believe that what's gonna happen here is gonna be harmful for humanity. I think it could lead to the curing of all those diseases. I think it'll be very beneficial. But my point is that if you are a doomer and you're terrified of recursive self improvement, why in the world are you supporting this company, this IPO? Why are giving them such a pass? You know, why are you celebrating over Jensen's fall? All he was doing was promoting open source, which is manifestly behind the closed model frontier. Right? There's no recursive self improvement there. So the whole thing is very backwards. And what it suggests to me is that all these safety groups don't really care about safety. They care about something else. It's not the real agenda. If safety was a real agenda, they'd be way more concerned about the Clog Constitution training the superintelligence to be a new species. What they seem to want is, to your point, Freeberg, is extreme centralization of power in the hands of the government. They want all the models and all the chips to be controlled by the government. The government's gonna surveil you, spy on you. It'll have backdoors all over the place, and that's what they seem to want. It's a scary future.
David Friedberg (01:23:29): Notice how no one in congress is like, oh, let's go after anthropic bailiffs. Wanna go after everyone else.
Jason Calacanis (01:23:36): Yeah.
David Sacks (01:23:36): Because anthropic is offering
Jason Calacanis (01:23:38): them
David Sacks (01:23:38): power, ultimate power.
Jason Calacanis (01:23:39): It's gonna be great when we all are all invited to the White House, by AOC in 2028. It's great to see you, AOC. Alright, everybody. Another amazing episode of the Ireland Pocas. We'll see next time. Bye bye.
Chamath Palihapitiya (01:23:53): Love you, boys. Bye bye.
David Sacks (01:24:21): We
Jason Calacanis (01:24:27): should all just get a room and just have one big huge orgy because they're all just useless. It's like it's like sexual tension that they just need to release somehow. Let